4 ms·
I never understood the stigma behind a completely natural and necessary process that half of all people have.
by StavrosK 11y ago
I never understood the stigma behind a completely natural and necessary process that half of all people have.
- gallamine 11y agoIn American culture is pretty taboo to have a conversation about defecation - that's a process that all people have! It might not make sense, but it isn't unusual.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tomp 11y agoI agree completely. Personally, I don't recall ever witnessing this stigma, apart from the general disinterest in this topic. Having said that, I don't understand the current movement of glorifying and promoting menstruation (e.g. [1], [2]). Sure, it's natural, but it's also rather yucky - just like shitting and pissing. But I'd still appreciate if I don't see photos of shit, menstruation, or sperm on my Facebook. [1] http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/menstruation-themed-photo-series-artist-censored-by-instagram-says-images-are-to-demystify-taboos-10144331.html http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/menstrua... [2] http://www.buzzfeed.com/rossalynwarren/a-woman-ran-a-marathon-free-bleeding-to-take-a-stand-against http://www.buzzfeed.com/rossalynwarren/a-woman-ran-a-maratho...
- speeder 11y agoI am from Brazil, I had never heard of a taboo in the open, but after I started to have long term girlfriends, all of them tried to not use the word "menses" in Portuguese, from methods that I think are stupid (writing only "m" instead) to the outright infuriating (using ambiguous and hard to understand euphemisms), it annoyed me a lot, and I argued with all of them about it, never worked, they never explained that behavior and continued it.
- tomp 11y agoIsn't that about the same as people saying "I'm going to the toilet for number 2" instead of "I'm going to the toilet to shit"?
- StavrosK 11y agoIt's more like saying "I'm going to the back" in the amount of ambiguity in the phrase. Saying "number two" is clear in its meaning.
- StavrosK 11y agoYeah, in Greece they also say "I'm indisposed", and it's a generally-known euphemism for "I'm on my period", but you never really know if they're on their period or if they're ill.
- StavrosK 11y ago> Personally, I don't recall ever witnessing this stigma I've seen it in things like my mom asking me whether I'd be uncomfortable getting her pads from the supermarket, which was pretty puzzling to me. I guess it's to women what buying condoms is to men, maybe.
- xyzzyz 11y agoIt's not unlike the stigma behind a completely natural and necessary process that almost all of people have, which is defecation. Operationally speaking, the two are very similar. So, why is there a stigma behind defecation?
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoWhy is there a stronger stigma behind menstruation, though? In many societies, people who had recently menstruated were seen as "unclean", yet defecation did not have the same stigma.
- moron4hire 11y agoI think that's not entirely correct. In those same societies, the left hand is considered "unclean" because of its association with wiping.
- marrs 11y agoWhat societies are those?
- jacquesm 11y agohttp://www.come-and-hear.com/editor/america_3.html http://www.come-and-hear.com/editor/america_3.html For instance.
- marrs 11y agoNot having any experience with orthodox Judaism, it's hard to put those passages into context. It's rather hard to decide what to make of that page. It seems to have an agenda, though I'm not sure I understand what it is.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoJewish society in biblical times comes to mind. I'm sure it's not unique.
- 11y ago
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThe stigma is almost certainly connected to misogyny. By stigmatising the bodily functions of most women, you stigmatise them.
- moron4hire 11y agoI understand what you're trying to say about patriarchy, and it's a problem, but that said... I and 100% of people have a few completely natural and necessary processes that we go through on a pretty much daily basis that are so stigmatized they have a special room in our houses dedicated to making sure we can do them in private. I'm talking about defecating and urinating. Can you imagine if--once a month, like clockwork--you got really bad IBS and couldn't help but visibly leak diarrhea into your pants? Would you celebrate "I have monthly track marks", or would you develop coping mechanisms to try to hide it? And before anyone complains about "you can't compare pooping and having a period", uh, poo is brown because it's mostly dead red blood cells. It is a process for expelling material my body can no longer use. About as comparable as apples and oranges, which is to say, fairly comparable, because they're both sweet, round fruits that grow on trees and contain their own seeds. We generally don't share the details of what we do with our bodily fluids with other people. I mean, we call public toilets "restrooms" because we can't bring ourselves to admit to what is going on in there. Should our culture be so prudish about bodily functions? I don't know, but that is certainly the case as of right now. And it's applied pretty evenly, regardless of sex. So I would say it's easily "understandable". [0] I usually leave sweating and fatigued, so I don't know how much "rest" I'm receiving in there. Suppose I need to lay off the Chipotle. Which brings up another point, severe abdominal cramping isn't unique to menstruation, either.
- cperciva 11y agoThe colouring of faeces is due to the breakdown of heme, but faeces should not contain any nontrivial quantity of intact dead red blood cells.
- StavrosK 11y ago> I understand what you're trying to say about patriarchy I wasn't trying to say anything about patriarchy, just to be clear. > Would you celebrate "I have monthly track marks", or would you develop coping mechanisms to try to hide it? Neither, probably. If everyone got it, I'd say "I have my IBS these days" and everyone would understand. > We generally don't share the details of what we do with our bodily fluids with other people. Sure, but there's a difference between "holy shit this period is so goopy, it's like I have a second nose" and "this period is giving me pretty bad cramps". > So I would say it's easily "understandable". My issue is not about describing periods in detail, I understand why people don't want to invoke images in other people's heads. I'm just puzzled about not even being able to say "I have my period this week", which is like saying "I have diarrhoea", it's not really that descriptive unless the recipient tries hard to imagine it, in which case, it's their problem :P
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoIt has all the unreasonable stigmas of bodily functions and some of the unreasonable stigmas around sex and the much of the unreasonable stigma around puberty.
- falcolas 11y agoIt's at least partially due to the process being "unnatural" in a historical context. Women were historically pregnant much of their lives, so having a period would have been relatively uncommon. It's also been explicitly stigmatized in many different religious contexts, from the Old Testament to Native American cultures. Is any of this right? Probably not. But for better or worse, we're driven as much by our history as our intellect.