4 ms·
Ok the real question is, how does this compares to CentOS/"Prominent Linux Vendor" relationship And Linux Mint also recompiles and replaces the trademarks no?
by raverbashing 11y ago
Ok the real question is, how does this compares to CentOS/"Prominent Linux Vendor" relationship
And Linux Mint also recompiles and replaces the trademarks no?
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> And Linux Mint also recompiles and replaces the trademarks no? Sure, but presumably that took a lot of effort.
- rincebrain 11y agoActually, the claim made by someone[1] in one of the replies on LWN was that Mint ended up getting a license from Canonical, so if you wanted to spin off from Linux Mint, you too would require a license from Canonical or having to dive in and rip out any Ubuntu trademarks. [1] - https://lwn.net/Articles/665350/ https://lwn.net/Articles/665350/
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoDear God.
- lmm 11y agoDid you read Garrett's post? Prominent Linux Vendor segregates its trademarks into three packages and documents that you need to replace those specific packages (and only those) with versions that don't infringe their trademarks if you wish to redistribute.
- raverbashing 11y agoI had read it yes (and missed that part), but curiously that part refers to Fedora (which was traditionally more liberal), not RHEL
- Already__Taken 11y agoAs I understand it Fedora is where RHEL comes from is it not? So Redhat replace in their own branding just like everyone else.
- lmm 11y agoIt's not as simple as that. Fedora is used as a kind of public beta for RHEL which is much slower moving and more server-oriented; there's not a direct translation from one to the other.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- makomk 11y agoAccording to the comments on Matthew Garrett's blog, RHEL has an almost identical clause in its EULA: in order to redistribute open source code in RHEL, you must "remove and replace all occurrences of Red Hat trademarks". (Unless they've changed it, Red Hat also has a policy that redistributing their Linux kernel patchset they supply is a breach of contract and they will terminate support and updates for anyone caught doing this. Yes, they're working around the GPL to stop people redistributing GPL code.) This is apparently why CentOS takes so long to track new RHEL releases: https://lwn.net/Articles/417849/ https://lwn.net/Articles/417849/
- felipeerias 11y agoLink to Red Hat's policy (see section on publishing modified software on page 5): https://www.redhat.com/f/pdf/corp/RH-3573_284204_TM_Gd.pdf https://www.redhat.com/f/pdf/corp/RH-3573_284204_TM_Gd.pdf I'm not an expert, but to be honest this sounds pretty similar to what Garrett is complaining about: "You may not name or brand your product “Red Hat” or use the Red Hat trademarks in any way, either on your product or in related advertising." "You must use a different trademark for your product that will not cause confusion with the trademarks of Red Hat, will not indicate or imply that your product originates from or is sponsored or approved by Red Hat, and which otherwise complies with applicable trademark laws." "You may not state that your product contains Red Hat Linux or Red Hat Enterprise Linux."
- mjg59 11y agoLater on the same page they tell you what you have to do to meet those conditions. The fact that Canonical won't do that is what I'm unhappy about.
- felipeerias 11y agoAre you referring to point D, "modify the files identified as REDHAT-LOGOS and ANACONDA-IMAGES"? Because that doesn't seem sufficient to fully comply with all of the previous points. I do agree that Canonical haven't been clear enough on this issue but, in my humble opinion, their policies don't seem all that different from Red Hat's.
- spdionis 11y agoI dont understand why people ignore Linux Mint when commenting as a consumer desktop OS. It works wonders and it's really easy to use.