4 ms·
The popular perception is that they build it for themselves with what they want in an OS and don't give a shit otherwise. Hence, a significant gap between what
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
The popular perception is that they build it for themselves with what they want in an OS and don't give a shit otherwise. Hence, a significant gap between what most want and what it is. It's mostly a difference in focus and philosophy that won't win a popularity contest.
There are technical limitations as others have noted. The attitude and focus, though, I think is what kept OpenBSD in their own niche.
- morganvachon 11y agoIndeed, OpenBSD is great at what it does and like Slackware on the Linux side, it isn't for everyone but it certainly is awesome in its own right. The only technical limitation I've run into as far as using it as a daily driver OS, is that it can be a bit slow even on very fast hardware. It's simply not optimized for desktop use, though it is certainly usable with a few tweaks. It's great for older hardware too, where the speed issue is relative. In fact, I've found it to be a perfect fit for a couple of old laptops in my collection.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoIt has many technical limitations that I'm aware of. Large TCB, less fault-tolerance, supports less COTS hardware than Linux, less automation software, less multicore, desktop as you mentioned, weaker in virtualization, no mandatory controls on apps, less integration with cutting-edge security tech (eg CheriBSD, SoftBound)... could be more but that's off top of head. Harder to say whether it's easier to bring OpenBSD to where competition is on these or to bring competition's code to where OpenBSD is, esp as some safety/security tech makes that less relevant. Hard to say... Regardless, it's a high-quality UNIX that's worth having around. I'm glad to see them improving in areas where it's weaker while not throwing away strengths like some projects would.
- krylon 11y ago> In fact, I've found it to be a perfect fit for a couple of old laptops in my collection. I recently inherited an old-ish laptop (I don't know the exact year it was built, but it has a Windows Vista sticker on it, so 2007-2009, I guess) and decided to install OpenBSD on it, mainly because I have always wanted to give it a try on real hardware as opposed to a VM. I was pleasantly surprised to find that all the pieces I care about (sound, video, wifi, ethernet, ...) Just Worked(tm). That was nice. More heavyweight applications like Firefox or Clementine slow the system down substantially, but otherwise it runs nicely.
- hackuser 11y ago> More heavyweight applications like Firefox or Clementine slow the system down substantially Systems in 2007 had no problem running Firefox. I'm surprised to hear it has a significant impact. Maybe Firefox has become much more resource intensive? That would surprise me because processors haven't gotten much faster, Mozilla has focused on reducing memory consumption and improving responsiveness, and because of the rise of mobile, a resource-constrained environment.
- krylon 11y agoThe system has 2GB of RAM, so that should not be a problem. However, the CPU is a Celeron M, which is really, really slow.
- pjmlp 11y agoIf only the other UNIXes (commercial or free) valued the code correctness and safety as they do. :)
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI agree. Especially FreeBSD as it kicks ass in terms of features and general stability. I think them pausing for a week out of every month or even a few days to audit plenty of critical code & do bugfixes wouldn't have set them behind much. Maybe incorporate more mitigation tech out of OpenBSD, grsecurity, etc while they're at it. Matter of fact, I can prove it with an example [1] that predates OpenBSD's approach while succeeding in market at least while under good management (sighs). Used a combo of good design, OS features, and code quality to achieve reliability most still haven't beaten. Coding approach, which I'm focusing on here, was to alternate between developing features and fixing bugs with tests (esp regression) run on weekends while developers were off. One week build stuff, tests on weekend, one week fixing by priority, rinse, repeat. That simple. OpenBSD took it further with security focus and systematic audits but this basic method produced robust and marketable code. So, what's other commercial players' excuse? ;) [1] http://www.itec.suny.edu/scsys/vms/ovmsdoc073/ovms_archived/pdf/BUILD_DEPEND_SYS.PDF http://www.itec.suny.edu/scsys/vms/ovmsdoc073/ovms_archived/...
- hackuser 11y ago> a significant gap between what most want and what it is I've heard this, but what exactly is missing? Do you mean features such as a hypervisor?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoMentioned a few here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10615620 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10615620