7 ms·
There is no language instinct (2014)
- mitchtbaum 11y agoI only scanned through this very long article to pull out useful info.. I got this: > [Chomsky] concluded that [children] must be born with a rudimentary body of grammatical knowledge – a ‘Universal Grammar’ – written into the human DNA. > ... Chomsky is plain wrong > What is in dispute is the claim that knowledge of language itself – the language software – is something that each human child is born with. > Our brains really are ‘language-ready’ in the following limited sense: they have the right sort of working memory to process sentence-level syntax, and an unusually large prefrontal cortex that gives us the associative learning capacity to use symbols in the first place. > And of course, language doesn’t need to be spoken. ..linguistic meaning can be conveyed in multiple ways: in speech, by gestured signs, on the printed page or computer screen. It does not depend upon a particular medium for its expression. > As it happens, cognitive neuroscience research from the past two decades or so has begun to lift the veil on where language is processed in the brain. The short answer is that it is everywhere. > Why is it that today, only humans have language, the most complex of animal behaviours? > [Early humans'] new ecological situation would have led, inexorably, to changes in human behaviour. ... This allows us to picture the emergence of language as a gradual process from many overlapping tendencies. > We see this instinct [(cooperation)] at work in human infants as they attempt to acquire their mother tongue. Children have far more sophisticated learning capacities than Chomsky foresaw. They are able to deploy sophisticated intention-recognition abilities from a young age, perhaps as early as nine months old, in order to begin to figure out the communicative purposes of the adults around them. And this is, ultimately, an outcome of our co‑operative minds.
- Retra 11y agoI always like to frame this kind of thing using the term "appropriateness." We can imagine an amoeba having a rudimentary ability to detect whether its surroundings are hostile or not and employ an instinctual response to evade it. It's not much of a leap from there to say humans have a social instinct, and that our ability to evade hostility has become strongly correlated with our ability to identify behaviors that are appropriate in context. And language is, in an abstract sense, just this: choosing appropriate actions. Maybe they're words. Maybe they're intonations. Or other social norms. Nobody learns 'just' language as a child, they learn a whole way of life. They learn "swearing is wrong," not simply "this is the proper syntax for swearing." And they feel its wrongness when they swear. You can't know what swear words mean if you can't feel that, and you probably won't be able to survive very well as a human if you can't determine what behavior is appropriate or not in your situation.
- chillacy 11y agoOn his point of DNA not having enough information: > But recent research in neurobiology suggests that human DNA just doesn’t have anything like the coding power needed to do this How could the author arrive at this conclusion without knowing what the universal grammar which needs encoding is? And beyond that, what if such a universal grammar is simply an artifact of existing structures accounted for in DNA?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hasenj 11y agoI've been thinking lately that our brains might have evolved for communication using language. The fact that they can also do philosophy, math, science and engineering is just an unintended (yet fortunate) consequence of having enough capability to handle language. Learning a foreign language can be as challenging as learning to program or building a software system. It takes a lot of dedication and practice. Involves using a lot of memory and pattern recognition, and all the "intellectual" capacities that are needed to handle a large engineering project.
- simondedalus 11y agothis article is bad. chomsky and his ilk have always acknowledged the wide variety of linguistic behavior; that's the whole point. universal grammar is the parameters to be set (what sounds have meaning? what word order is used? etc). learning a language is the setting of those parameters. humans may have linguistic "knowledge" that they're born with, they may not... but this article is beside the point.
- rspeer 11y agoThis article is very much on point when it comes to the language debate, you're just taking an oddly hedged position on it. Chomsky and his ilk have made very strong, very specific claims about language in the past. They have claimed that certain combinations of linguistic parameters are impossible, and that certain features are shared by all languages. They have actively denied the wide variety of linguistic behavior until the evidence piles up enough that they change the topic. Followers of this brand of linguistics have resisted empirical tests of these claims, and some of them have academically attacked those who disagree. And yet these claims have been chipped away anyway until all that's left is a really vague claim that most humans can communicate using recursion. Your second paragraph seems at odds with your first. If these parameters exist to be set, that's knowledge. Knowing that word order is a thing that can vary is knowledge. Chomsky says we are born with this knowledge. Some who disagree with him say we aren't born with it, and that we have to learn it from experience. In the part where you hedge and say "they may not...", you're surprisingly agreeing with this article more than Chomsky. Chomsky would say "Humans absolutely have linguistic knowledge they are born with. Anyone who disagrees is a behaviorist charlatan." Chomsky's linguistics was indeed a way better model of learning than behaviorism, but that was 60 years ago and we need a better model now.
- 4bpp 11y agoRight in its headline, the article makes the powerful claim that there is no language instinct (which I assume is to be read as equivalent to "innate language knowledge"). Unless you use some very specific notion of knowledge that makes this false, this is a much stronger claim than the claim that there is innate language knowledge - the reason is the same as why the claim that humans are all born with equal abilities is a stronger claim than the claim to the contrary. Now, you could say that Chomsky actually made the claim that /all/ humans have /the same/ innate language knowledge, which then of course would be as probabilistically absurd as the claim that all humans have none - but this is so obviously false (considering mental damage, mutations etc.) that surely everyone involved will have understood that what was meant was not this but rather some statement like "most humans (...)" or "central examples of the category of humans (...)" or "humans with high probability are hardwired to have a probabilistic affinity to interpret language in terms of these structural universals". (edit: Note though that "All humans have no innate language knowledge" is still orders of magnitude more unlikely than "All humans have some common particular set of innate language knowledge" - the latter just requires the highly unlikely even that the random drawing of every single human's innate language knowledge came out to some particular value, but the former requires that the random drawing of all of humanity's innate language knowledge came out to the particular set of preconceptions that you consider to be "no preconceptions", and then that the random drawing of every single human's innate knowledge also came out to that value. Think likelihood of discovering an animal species all of whose living members have exactly the same colour of fur at 24-bit granularity, versus the likelihood of discovering one all of whose living members have #F45080 fur.)
- LesZedCB 11y agoI"m not sure this is completely related, but every time I think about Chomsky and language and universal grammar, this comes to mind and still leaves me baffled and amazed. This is a short 5 minute video on whistling Turkish. In a village in Turkey, they uphold the tradition of communication by whistling phonemes. It is a direct mapping of Turkish to Whistling Turkish, where every phoneme in Turkish has a whistling equivalent. The difference is it uses pitch changes as phonemes. It blows my mind. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQf38Ybo1IY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQf38Ybo1IY
- mbrock 11y agoThere's a similar tradition of whistled Spanish on the Canary Islands. It was used to talk across mountain valleys and stuff. UNESCO designated it as some kind of cultural heritage, I think.
- panglott 11y agoWhistled language isn't all that uncommon: it also happens in some Inuit languages and tonal languages. The even have different airstream mechanisms IIRC: Inuit whistled languages use palatal whistling, whereas on Silbo Gomero (pardon the spelling) you whistle into your hands. Check out the Piraha channls, where they also have "hum speech", "yell speech", "musical speech". http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003175.html http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003175.h...
- igravious 11y ago"the chances of two individuals getting the same chance mutation, at exactly the same time, is even less credible. And so, according to the theory of the language instinct, the world’s first language-equipped human presumably had no one to talk to." This is why I believe that if there are any genetic encodings for language (whether either specific to language alone or non-specific but used also by language, if you get my drift) they must have occurred with twins who were then able to communicate more effectively with each other relative to their peers and so they survived and so did their offspring and their genes spread throughout the gene pool. I know it's a wacky idea but it gets around the rebuttal of "presumably had no one to talk to." And sure, it's an unlikely event but we're talking hundreds of thousands of years here, thousands of generations, billions of people.
- oxplot 11y agoHmm, given that a few hundred line python script fed with large stream of characters can start producing sentences with correct grammar (however mostly nonsensical), I agree that we, given the complexity of our neural networks, don't need any pre-existing machinery to learn languages.
- emn13 11y agoBut in order to do that, the "model" (i.e. the python program itself) needs to be carefully selected. Most python programs - or other programs - won't do this. Indeed, you need to construct the program to pay special attention to particular kinds of statistics, and the choice of those structures would correspond to the hypothetical "universal grammar" - at least, as far as I understand without being overly encumbered by any expertise on the matter ;-).
- oxplot 11y agoI wrote the parent comment on the go so here's more details. I'm specifically referring to the python script [1] mentioned in the article titled "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Recurrent Neural Networks" [2]. I don't know much about ANNs but after a quick glance at the code, it seems to be setting up a generic three layer RNN. Based on this, I would argue that ability to learn patterns in sequence of data is all that's needed to learn a language. Calling it a "grammar" ties it too much to concept of language since such learning ability extends beyond human languages. [1]: https://gist.github.com/karpathy/d4dee566867f8291f086 https://gist.github.com/karpathy/d4dee566867f8291f086 [2]: http://karpathy.github.io/2015/05/21/rnn-effectiveness/ http://karpathy.github.io/2015/05/21/rnn-effectiveness/
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y agoChomsky based his original argument that language is an innate ability of the human species on a famous mathematical result by Mark E. Gold, from a paper titled "Language identification in the limit" published in 1967 [1] Gold's result basically says that it's impossible for a learner to learn a non-finite language (which means anything from regular languages and above) without access to an infinite number of examples, both positive and negative, of the language, or failing that, access to an oracle that knows the language perfectly and can confirm or reject the learner's evolving model of the language. In some versions, the oracle must respond to errors with a negative counter-example, teaching the learner why its model is wrong ("if the sentence you just formed was correct then you could form this other sentence, which is obviously wrong"). As far as I know, Gold's result still stands. So I think you may be overestimating the power of the python script you link to. I should say that I'm aware of Karpathy's project, and it's really cool (or awesome if you prefer), but reproducing text is not the same as learning language. In other words, if you expect any program to learn language, you better have infinite data to train it with and also an infinite amount of time. I stress that this doesn't only apply to human languages. You can try teaching a network to learn the syntax of Java, for example. You'll still need infinite resources, or an Oracle. ++ Edited to remove unfortunate scare quotes and also to add: if you could machine-learn a language, even "just" a CFG, we wouldn't need to write parsers for programming language compilers anymore. It would suffice to present a machine learning algorithm with some examples (a lot of them probably) and the algorithm would form a model of the language, that we could then use as a parser. This is far from the state of the art today, however. __________________ [1] http://web.mit.edu/~6.863/www/spring2009/readings/gold67limit.pdf http://web.mit.edu/~6.863/www/spring2009/readings/gold67limi...
- akkartik 11y agoMy favorite theory of the origin of language: http://www.amazon.com/The-Symbolic-Species-Co-evolution-Language/dp/0393317544 http://www.amazon.com/The-Symbolic-Species-Co-evolution-Lang.... It unfolds a bit like a murder mystery, so I won't spoil the ending for you. If the middle section seems a bit of a slog -- persevere!
- Xophmeister 11y agoCtrl+F Everett ...I thought as much
- wodenokoto 11y agoMind sharing what the impact of the result of that search is supposed to be?
- Pitarou 11y agoDaniel Everett is an anthropologist who has made some extraordinary claims about an Amazonian tribe called the Pirahã.
- panglott 11y agoOK... but so what? If you're doing a general interest article on debates in linguistics in the last 10 years, you're going to end up covering Everett's work and its implications for Chomsky's theory du jour. This article's discussion of Everett and recursion was pretty brief, overall. http://chronicle.com/blogs/linguafranca/2012/03/28/poisonous-dispute/ http://chronicle.com/blogs/linguafranca/2012/03/28/poisonous... http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/004592.html http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/004592.h...
- GarvielLoken 11y agoIt's not about the brain, it's about the body. Right brain innate connection to ones own body and to the world. We know that there are nouns because the body senses objects. We know there are verbs because the body can make movements. We know there are adjectives because the objects differs. It's a very left brain dominated view that would even contemplate that a language system would evolve free of interaction with the world, only through dna construct some language organ. And language is probably a product of singing. Checkout "The Master and His Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World". Singing is used to share feelings in larger groups then ordinary grooming permit. Language is a systematization of singing. That is why music evokes feeling response more readily then words in ordinary speech, speech evolved later.