3 ms·
> I.e. do they consider the animal itself dirty, or its inherent genetic structure? Dirty? That's a really really really bad translation for not-kosher. It has
by ars 11y ago
> I.e. do they consider the animal itself dirty, or its inherent genetic structure?
Dirty? That's a really really really bad translation for not-kosher. It has nothing whatsoever to do with cleanliness.
Anyway for the purposes of this meat neither of those two options cover the topic.
The animal itself is what is kosher or not kosher. It has physical signs and those decide if it's kosher or not.
There is a second issue that something derived from something non-kosher is also not kosher.
So CO2 (for seltzer) from beer is not kosher for passover, but CO2 from combustion is, despite both being identical.
But, there is a concept of nullified, i.e. diluted. If someone non-kosher is unintentionally diluted in something kosher at a 1/60 level it becomes nullified and ignored. (So CO2 from the atmosphere is fine for passover even if it originally was from beer.)
Except, if that diluted item is considered "primary", i.e. it's something that even at a 1/60th level becomes important in the final product.
So here we have a single cell from an animal - it certainly is less than 1/60th of the final product, but since it is primary to that product, which could not exist without it, that single cell can not be diluted.
i.e. you have to start with a kosher cell.
A much more complicated question is if it's considered meat with regard to mixing meat and dairy. But the question is academic only since it would be rabbinically considered like meat because it looks like meat and you should not create a misleading situation.
And from the length of this reply you can start to understand why Judaism is such an academic and logically oriented religion with such an enormous quantity of scholarly books. You start with God-given unprovable axioms and generate everything else with logic, one item building upon the next, all ultimately sourced from the Torah (but you need some serious knowledge to be able to trace each law). It's also how Judaism has survived so long - using this method you can extend the law to cover novel situations.
- jld89 11y ago"logically oriented religion"... o...k....