3 ms·
> But because budgets have to balance, the current system has the advantage that it can have lower marginal tax rates on higher income earners. That isn't a ve
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> But because budgets have to balance, the current system has the advantage that it can have lower marginal tax rates on higher income earners.
That isn't a very strong argument. Assuming the basic income and associated taxation is calculated to approximate the same level of redistribution of wealth as the existing welfare system, the amount a person making a given level of income would have to have their taxes increased by in order to balance the budget is only equal to the amount they themselves would receive from the basic income but would not have qualified for in a means tested welfare system. For high income earners that amount is negligible because the basic income constitutes such a small proportion of their total income, and even then it has no effect on their effective tax rate (i.e. net transfers with the government; taxes paid less basic income), only that small change to the marginal rate needed to keep the effective rate the same.
And in particular what is really happening is that the disincentive (which is created by any taxation for any purpose) is being spread more evenly throughout the population, which all else equal can be expected to have less effect on behaviour than concentrating the effect on a subgroup which will then be much more compelled to react to it.
Moreover, how the taxes are collected is separate from the basic income. If we find that it is for some strange reason better to charge a higher marginal rate to lower income people than higher income people then we can have a basic income and yet still do that.
- google15 11y agoAnd in particular what is really happening is that the disincentive (which is created by any taxation for any purpose) is being spread more evenly throughout the population Agreed, which is why I object to your statement that: We already know how to design a program that won't discourage work. It's not that basic income discourages work more or less, but that it evens out the marginal tax rate. This might be a good or a bad thing, but your original post contains no argument either way. You run a very strong risk of the reader misinterpreting what you are saying, and believing that there will be a uniform improvement in incentives across the whole population. which all else equal can be expected to have less effect on behaviour than concentrating the effect on a subgroup which will then be much more compelled to react to it. I think the main argument behind the current system is that low income people need the money, and therefore are less affected by the marginal tax rate. Moreover, how the taxes are collected is separate from the basic income. If we find that it is for some strange reason better to charge a higher marginal rate to lower income people than higher income people then we can have a basic income and yet still do that. Either "basic income" should be used to denote a flat tax plus basic income, or a varying marginal tax plus basic income. Your first post implies the former to the exclusion of the latter. I think you are changing the definition because it's important to you that basic income "win", but really there are two separate issues, which are negative taxation vs welfare, and fixed vs varying effective marginal tax rates. Each of these issues should be decided independently on their own merits.
- google15 11y ago(reply in place of broken edit functionality) Actually I think the main reason why we have a high marginal tax rate on low income people, is a deeper reason which is that incentives on the bottom end are more "expensive" because they propagate upwards. E.g. to incentivize a person earning $10000 a year, you need to give then $X for every dollar they earn, but then these affects the after tax earnings of everyone earning above $10000 a year. Sorry if this is vague but this comes from various results/methods in mechanism design theory. Unfortunately as is often the case, the advocates of basic income (not you in particular) are too political, while the economists don't chime in on political matters when they should.
- evanpw 11y agoI think you're overthinking this. If you want to give a benefit to low-income people, then either you phase out slowly and it costs a lot, or you phase out quickly and you have high effective tax rates. And the people passing the laws probably pay a lot more attention to total budget cost than to the effects on effective marginal tax rates, so you end up with a lot of programs that have fast phase-outs.
- google15 11y agoThe budget has to balance, so the question is not how much the system costs, but what are the incentive effects on the (wealthier) people who pay for it. If you agree with me that phasing the benefit out slowly "costs a lot" then you actually agree with my reasoning.
- evanpw 11y agoMaybe I'm just misunderstanding, but you're talking as if the current system was consciously selected because of some inherent advantages it has over the alternatives. I don't think that's really true, and I would argue that the high marginal tax rates on low-income people are less the result of a careful analysis of trade-offs, and more the result of a flaw in the incentive structure for law-makers (on-budget costs look worse than off-budget costs).