5 ms·
I am dreading the first time I visit someone with one of these. I wonder how they will respond to my request to turn it off? offense? understanding? pity and ri
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I am dreading the first time I visit someone with one of these. I wonder how they will respond to my request to turn it off? offense? understanding? pity and ridicule?
Amazon and Google have both figured out that the current commodity of value isn't oil, and isn't energy in general, it is information. The people with more information have an advantage over the people with less information. That advantage can be tactical, commercial, or personal. So collecting information while being helpful gives you a much better asset than simply being helpful does.
We've read stories of cops misusing information databases to check up on their ex-spouses or future dates, Google SREs reading people's mail, and NSA analysts passing around "juicy" intercepts with prurient but no security value. We've got people on the other side of these piles of information and those people are fallible, and susceptible to bribes, and generally susceptible to poor judgement.
What is worse, is that the "service" that something like Alexa offers is pretty credibly offered in a modest cluster of modern machines with GPUs. I would expect that a 32 node Jetson cluster could provide reliable general speech recognition and execution. But the illusion is that you need a "big cloud" of machines to do this. You don't.
So I'm all in favor of these interesting technologies helping folks out, but I really wish we would step past 'cloud' and into a 'house cluster' which, like your furnace or HVAC system, does the work locally and protects your privacy. It is a company I have seriously considered starting twice now. Even in the US people can get multi-megabit connectivity to the Internet from their home, there is no reason any more why you shouldn't be able to access your pictures, your media, your email, and communities by talking to your server in your house. The challenge is turning it into an appliance. That is doable I believe.
- rsync 11y ago"So I'm all in favor of these interesting technologies helping folks out, but I really wish we would step past 'cloud' and into a 'house cluster' which, like your furnace or HVAC system, does the work locally and protects your privacy." This is the model, and it largely already exists. If you're willing to give up the most candy and fluffy of high tech "features" (the ones that break all the time and are of questionable value anyway) you can have a very nice home control system that has no network connectivity and zero wireless emanations. It's also more tasteful. LCD screens in the living area are the new formica.
- DanBlake 11y agoThe device does not communicate with amazon.com until you say "alexa" and the code/hardware for that is all done on the device itself. So its not listening and streaming everything, all the time. It is listening all the time, yes- But only for the word 'alexa' - If it hears that word, then it starts talking to amazon.com and starts doing voice recognition. This is very easy to verify yourself with a network monitor. Do you ask people with iphones or androids to turn them off when you are close because its listening for "hey siri" or "ok google" ? If you asked me to turn mine off when visiting, I would happily oblige you- And then label you as a nutcase who has lined their walls with tinfoil.
- CaptSpify 11y ago> The device does not communicate with amazon.com until you say "alexa" and the code/hardware for that is all done on the device itself. So its not listening and streaming everything, all the time. It is listening all the time, yes- But only for the word 'alexa' - If it hears that word, then it starts talking to amazon.com and starts doing voice recognition. This is very easy to verify yourself with a network monitor. My personal issue with this is: That could be changed at anytime without any warning. Yes, I tend towards the tinfoil side of things, but the fact is: You can't really always know that, unless you are consistently monitoring the connection.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI've got a Moto-X android phone and I changed its voice activation function to be the phrase "Kirk to Enterprise" (geeky yes, but also very unlikely to be spoken in public) and what I've found is that the limited ML classifier in the phone hits it regularly. I suppose I could try something in Klingon. In the referenced article, the unit activated unintentionally as well. That is a nice way to say that your argument is unconvincing in that it depends on the ML classifier to recognize the 'wake' phrase reliably, and I have ample evidence that it has a number of false positives. And when it "wakes up" it is trying to figure out what you're asking it to do, and if you're not then you are perhaps in danger of it doing something you didn't intend. I eventually turned this feature off on my phone entirely, I could not make it reliable. And I expect to hear interesting stories of that time when someone's phone called or did something unexpected, because the technology makes it inevitable.
- Ixiaus 11y agoThis is actually what we're doing at Plum. We're making WiFi and Bluetooth enabled dimmer switches that are running Linux on-top of an ARM9. The primary software for controlling it is written in Erlang and we're using distributed consensus for providing "advanced lighting configuration and control features". Your light switches form a cluster in your own home. That's the first step (we're trying to launch a product) and ultimately the goal is enabling customers to completely sever the Plum cloud dependency. Right now if you want 100% of the features (schedules, scenes, provisioning, what-not), you have to connect them to the internet, but we want users to have all of the features without any need for Plum's servers. As it stands, about 40% of the features do not require Plum's cloud and actually don't even use it if it's available, so we're working in that direction. We've also talked about open sourcing a subset of the cloud infrastructure so that users could prop-up their own servers if they really wanted "remote control" of lights (which does matter to people). Privacy sensitive IoT devices are certainly possible but until more people care about their privacy, it will unfortunately be very niche and a bit of an after-thought to go the extra mile to provide services that can be decoupled from the "smart devices" in the home. Particularly so, considering there's a land grab happening in the IoT space right now and corporations are trying to dominate the home IoT platform. Humans, in a capitalist society, pretty reliably follow "ask for forgiveness, not permission". Which is interestingly at odds with the more fringe ethical philosophies of free software, privacy respecting software, and generally "ethical" software (that obviously needs explication but I won't go into it here).
- jacquesm 11y agoWhat kind of features beyond those that a normal dimmer provides do you add when you have a wifi/bluetooth enabled dimmer? Does that translate into 'you can control the light from your phone'? Or are there other things that I haven't thought of that a light can do other than being on/off or somewhere in between?
- nitrogen 11y agoResponding to various conditions and sensors (in my case a legacy Kinect), sequenced timers, coordinated scenes across multiple lights, etc. My devices don't connect to the Internet to do it, but the local network is required. I use Hue and DMX-512 myself, but any Wifi-enabled light could benefit. Nest-like machine learning (the thinking on which predates Nest) can later be added in a cloudless way that starts to anticipate what lights to turn on together, what actions should trigger what scenes, etc. Presumably Plum has similar ideas.
- emcq 11y agoAfter training, you could likely do this on a single node. You don't need that much compute for speech to text and then information retrieval.
- rayuela 11y agoThere are economies of scales to centralized cloud hardware and software services and more importantly to centralized information integration that, combined with the relative difficulty of valuing the price of the privacy we sacrifice, make private clusters an unfeasible market outcome. Cloud is inevitable at this point and I really don't think there's any way of getting around it.