4 ms·
I feel that was a mistake. I would prefer a nicely formatted web summary. I generally won't click on PDF links as they tend to be hard to read and usually overl
by andybak 11y ago
I feel that was a mistake. I would prefer a nicely formatted web summary. I generally won't click on PDF links as they tend to be hard to read and usually overly wordy.
I am also less likely to read an original paper over a web article unless I'm particularly interested in the topic.
I understand the policy for linking to original rather than commentary but there is sometimes value in a 'dumbed-down' summary.
- jimrandomh 11y agoI'll take the other side: I think it's almost always better to link to studies rather than to secondary sources reporting on them. I haven't looked closely at the study or the Vox article yet, but my experience has been that there's a major mismatch between study and the commentary more than half the time and it's always the study that's closer to truth.
- tomrod 11y agoWhy not require a comment to have the study source, and pin that to the top of the comment chain?
- qntmfred 11y agoThe vox link is at the top of the comments now, so potato, potato
- javajosh 11y agoAs an aside, does anybody actually say potato like "potato"?
- goodcanadian 11y agoWell, they say to-mah-to in Australia. However, they also say po-tay-to. I don't know of anywhere that it is pronounced po-tah-to, but I wouldn't rule it out.
- seekingcharlie 11y agoWe also pronounce tune as "choon", which results in a lot of weird looks if you're an Australian in the US.
- gwern 11y agoDoes HN have any such functionality?
- dang 11y agoWe're planning to implement some form of URL grouping. It's an open question what the best UI for that will be.
- jjoonathan 11y agoThe problem isn't dumbed-down summaries, the problem is that the dumbed-down summaries, especially those produced by people other than the original author, are often straight up wrong. Reading just the abstract, or abstract + figure captions, is a good compromise in my book.
- dang 11y agoActually I agree. Url changed back from http://economics.mit.edu/files/10849 http://economics.mit.edu/files/10849. HN generally prefers the best popular article on a specialized paper, with a link to the paper in the comments. An exception is papers on specialized topics the audience here is largely comfortable with, such as computing. I can't remember why we changed this one. It may be that we felt the Vox article was too baity, or perhaps that the HN discussion would be of higher quality if it were fed with vegetables rather than fruit. In any case it was more of an exception than the rule.