6 ms·
What I see here is a choice to bring up a child in an environment of an elite pursuit, in this case grandmaster-level chess. If that brings them joy, fine. But
by Zigurd 11y ago
What I see here is a choice to bring up a child in an environment of an elite pursuit, in this case grandmaster-level chess. If that brings them joy, fine. But it is not much different from children raised to perform at elite levels in sport, music, dance, etc. If they are happy that way, then good. But if they are not happy it is an avoidable misery.
If you have given your child the gift of a life of the mind, you really do not have to press them to be able to reach elite performance levels in the domains where, if you haven't sacrificed a normal-ish childhood, you have missed the boat.
If you avoid doing that, you give them the chance to excel in areas where one can have lifelong participation and growth.
- rm445 11y agoIf it were possible to create consistently world-class results in disparate fields by early specialisation and intensive training, could the world afford to ignore it? A decrease in total childhood happiness would be gladly accepted by every nation if more top performers in every field could be created. Perhaps one instead could hothouse a child in the life of the mind and produce a world-class young generalist, with the capacity to become a world-class specialist in a pursuit that makes them happy. I'm sure that happens a lot on an individual level. And indeed that could describe the goals of public education systems. But that's not exactly encouraging. We seem to have methods of intensive training that produce world-class prodigies in the arts and in competitive arenas - musical performers, athletes and chess. Academic hothousing seems a much more mixed bag.