4 ms·
I don't know if every child is a potential genius but I do know that not every child reaches their full potential. Its interesting that Polgar felt Chess was th
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I don't know if every child is a potential genius but I do know that not every child reaches their full potential. Its interesting that Polgar felt Chess was the ultimate expression of intelligence, why not mathematics? Or language?
As a parent when your children are young, I encourage you to encourage their curiosity in a healthy way, which leads to a life of wondering just why things are the way they are, and investing those questions in a productive way. Later in life its hard to rekindle the spark of curiosity, and early in life its easy to extinguish it.
- chdir 11y ago> Later in life its hard to rekindle the spark of curiosity, and early in life its easy to extinguish it Can this be backed up statistically ? Can a born genius have their spark extinguished by adverse circumstances or poor parenting ? I feel the exceptional ones march on their way to genius despite family support.
- qrendel 11y agoSeems a bit of a selection bias, in that no one who had their potential severely and permanently reduced from a young age is likely to be recognized as a genius. So you of course only end up recognizing "genius" in people who overcame whatever obstacles were presented them, or else had few to overcome in the first place. The best example I can think of is Chris Langan[1], though we only know who he is because he maintained some form of recognizable intellect in spite of his upbringing. Had his beatings led to debilitating psychological problems, brain damage, homelessness, or other things of that nature, we wouldn't be recognizing him as someone held back by his early childhood. Which sort of shows the inherent selection bias. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Langan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Langan
- ChuckMcM 11y agoIt would be challenging to design such an experiment for obvious reasons. I've observed the cohort of children associated with my friends. Nearly all the kids started out quite curious, but by middle school there was definite segmentation, and by college it was very much a smaller subset who were still out there asking questions and following up on the answers. I will also add that it is the curse of parenting that you cannot re-do the experiment. And so every choice you make, strict/lenient, forbid/allow, debate/fiat, talk/not-talk is full of questions about whether or not it would be better for your child if you acted in a different way. It is really stressful on the parents.
- tedks 11y ago>Its interesting that Polgar felt Chess was the ultimate expression of intelligence, why not mathematics? Or language? Says so in the article. Chess has a unified global ranking scheme so you can objectively measure your success in chess. The real tragedy is that these children grew up under Communism; there's another, even better, unified objective global ranking scheme he could have used if he raised them in a free country.
- zirkonit 11y agoNamely?
- ectoplasm 11y agoPresumably money. There's a discussion on the correlation between wealth and intelligence at LW with lots of links. Summary, from a quick read: being smart contributes to being rich, but it isn't necessary or sufficient. http://lesswrong.com/lw/jw5/how_much_wealth_is_produced_by_high_iq_people/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/jw5/how_much_wealth_is_produced_by_h...
- tedks 11y agoLikewise, in aggregate, being raised with a single-minded focus on chess is probably not necessary or sufficient for being successful on the scale of the article. Certainly most attempts to breed prodigies fail. Using a financial metric as opposed to a chess metric is an internal/external validity tradeoff that would support the claim that the parenting techniques used are useful in real-world scenarios. I think this is better because as many others have pointed out, how good you are at chess is usually not a factor in how successful a life you lead, whereas in the West, your net worth is basically a direct measurement of success.
- ectoplasm 11y agoYes, I agree, if you're optimizing for "success" you should optimize for "net worth", since for a lot of people those terms mean the same thing, no argument that this is the mainstream interpretation. Personally I believe that as far as financial success is concerned, how well you handle transactions is just as important as net worth (so it's best to have a lot of money and handle it really well), but that's impossible to quantify of course.
- thewarrior 11y agoWhat advice would you give to an adult trying to rekindle his curiosity and enthusiasm ? Too many of us have our idealism burnt out by dead end jobs and hectic lives.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoIdealism is a different thing, and curiosity in service to changing the world is probably doomed. It took a while until I was comfortable that the world was going to be what the world was going to be, and that change was very much slower to happen than I could envision it happening. For curiosity I read a lot to expose myself to new ideas, and follow up on things through journal articles, the occasional lab visit, and personal experimentation. It also helps to surround yourself with people who are curious, I identified that as one of the things that made college more "fun" than the office, everyone of my social group was excited to learn new things in college. And a small note on "hectic". I find when I'm trying to do too many things at the same time my life is "hectic" because every activity is taking away from some other important activity and I don't feel good about the one thing I am getting done, I feel bad about the 9 things I am not making progress on. My wife helped me recognize this pattern in me and to combat it I put longer schedules on things to allow each week to have its "thematic" goal, and all progress against that goal is "good" and any non-progress against other goals is "expected" so not bad. I find I get the same amount of stuff done I just feel much better about the progress. And while I totally acknowledge it could be a "pop psych trick", it keeps my level of happiness up.