6 ms·
This is really poor design from a UI/UX perspective. I spent 5 seconds on it and already uncovered the following problems: 1. It says nothing about Io on the f
by smt88 11y ago
This is really poor design from a UI/UX perspective. I spent 5 seconds on it and already uncovered the following problems:
1. It says nothing about Io on the front page except "A programming language". That's cute or edgy or whatever you want it to be, but it's not a good way to market a new language and spread adoption. No user should have to click to find out what your product is. There is way too much clicking here in general.
2. Terrible use of space. The "navigation" (if you can call it that) on the front page runs past the fold on my screen. The text is huge. On other pages, the text is tiny and hard to read because it's white-on-black.
3. Layout completely changes for different screen sizes. I know this is popular, but when it can be avoided, it's better to avoid it. When people see the same layout on all screens (or as close as you can get), it makes usage of the site faster. For a site that has language docs on it, this is really important.
- stevedekorte 11y agoThanks for the helpful feedback. It's a work in progress.
- smt88 11y agoYou'll learn more from watching someone use the site than you can learn from me. Here's a good exercise: 1. Write down the top 5 goals that someone coming to the site might want to reach. For example, "Find out what Io is" is probably #1, "See what the syntax looks like" is probably another, and "Learn the benefits over other languages" is probably a third. You'd be able to come up with a better list than me by looking at your analytics (what pages people visit most). 2. Write these goals down. Then ask someone who has never seen the site before to accomplish them right in front of you. Don't explain anything and don't interact with them until they're done. Make sure you keep a timer to see how long it takes. 3. After they're done, ask them what they found clear, what they found confusing, and what else they might want to see on the site.
- stevedekorte 11y agoGood points. I'd be very interested to see your version of the design if you had time to put something together.
- smt88 11y agoEdit: Rust's website has an open-source license[3]. You can copy the code and use it directly! That's great news because they host it on S3 with Jekyll, which is ridiculously inexpensive. I'm not an expert or a designer. Your users will show you how to improve the design because you'll see evidence of where they're getting tripped up. For example, if a certain page is the last one most people see before leaving the site (other than front page), then you can tell that page A) solves a problem, or B) causes people to lose interest. A good starting point is to look at other language sites and decide which ones seem friendliest and least friction-y. How easy it is to get started? As examples, I really like Rust's website[1], and Elm[2] is pretty good, too. Rust's site is great because it's readable, all the important stuff is above the fold, and it has big action buttons. They also give a fairly long example of syntax, which is important. I've even seen some languages that will show a snippet of code in an existing, comparable language, along with that same snippet translated into the new language. That's a great way to make your language accessible. 1. https://www.rust-lang.org https://www.rust-lang.org 2. http://elm-lang.org http://elm-lang.org 3. https://github.com/rust-lang/rust-www https://github.com/rust-lang/rust-www
- throwaway1 11y agoNo no no ... don't lift another project's website directly, it's tacky and will make your project look second-rate. Why do you insist on dominating the thread like this anyway? For my money, "reply to every replier" users are in a dead heat with "horse sense theory" users (like the one at the top of the HIV thread earlier, always followed w/ reams of "aw shucks, thanks!" replies) as the top nuisance on HN.
- smt88 11y ago> No no no ... don't lift another project's website directly, it's tacky and will make your project look second-rate. It's easy to change the look and feel drastically with CSS, while keeping the file structure and HTML layout. It's not any different than downloading or using a website template, which is itself not much different from using a library in any programming language. Standing on the shoulders of giants is a core value of software. > Why do you insist on dominating the thread like this anyway? I only mostly replied to people who were in my own comment thread. That's called a conversation. If I've inserted myself into anything unnecessarily, it's because usability and accessibility are really important to me. I want languages like this to succeed on their merits, rather than suffering due to unfriendly design. Plus I have friends and relatives with visual impairments.
- guelo 11y agoFWIW, I rather like it. It definitely stands out. The impression I got was bold, edgy, clean, opinionated, terse, not necessarily friendly. Not sure if that's the sense that you'd like to impart about the language.
- myg204 11y agoAgreed, I like the design. If you're here checking out the programming language, you're up for an original experience I'd say. I don't mind clicking 'about' to learn the minimum, and dive further on various sections...looks clean and I enjoy that. Personal opinion obviously.
- ternaryoperator 11y agoSteve, is the new website an indication that you're resuming work on Io?
- stevedekorte 11y agoI've been planning on doing a javascript port of Io when I have time but other projects keep coming up ( https://voluntary.net/bitmarkets/ https://voluntary.net/bitmarkets/ ). Anyone interested in helping with a JS port?
- _RPM 11y agoIt would be nice if it explained the internals a little bit. Like $X language is a interpreted duck typed language, or $X is a language with a jit that compiles to x86 byte code
- stevedekorte 11y agoGood suggestion. Thanks.
- chm 11y agoI want to add that the tutorial page is useless IMO. You should definitely consider adding syntax highlighting and using a different font. It's totally unclear. Sadly, after multiple clicks I still have no idea if the language could interest me, and I'm not going to look further. :/
- illumen 11y agoTutorial useful for me. Minimal website great. Like IO, I guess.
- stevedekorte 11y agoThanks for the suggestion. I've tried to fix it up a bit. What do you think?
- chm 11y agoLooks much better to me. I would also change the font family to a monospaced font, such as Fira Mono[1]. That would be two small modifications that lead to better readability IMO. If you want it even fancier, I found this page[2] that can highlight and format Io code... [1]:<link href='https://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Fira+Mono' https://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Fira+Mono' rel='stylesheet' type='text/css'> [2]: http://hilite.me/ http://hilite.me/
- nicerobot 11y agoAdditionally, light on dark is horrible for readability. That theme is great for imagery but it's doesn't provide valuable contrast for clearly rendering fonts. Programming docs are typically mostly text so should provide the best colors that support readability.
- imakesnowflakes 11y ago>Additionally, light on dark is horrible for readability. I have a hard time understanding this. Staring at a bright background hurt my eyes after a while. White text on a black background feels much more comfortable to read. What am I missing?
- Absentinsomniac 11y agoI agree with this. We've gotten a bit of flack on blog.darknedgy.net for this, and we've been putting off making a light-background alternative theme. I'll get around to it eventually because people want it, but I prefer the darker background with lighter text. It feels easier on the eyes for me, personally. And really, folks who have complained have been the minority anyway. For us anyway.
- smt88 11y agoYou should read the link I posted in the sibling to your comment[1]. You may personally feel that light-on-dark is better, but your visually-impaired users will disagree. This includes a huge number of older users, as eyes deteriorate significantly with age (even among people in their 40s and 50s). Also, you have no idea whether the complainers are in the minority or not. The people it bothered probably didn't stay long enough to figure out how to complain. Do you get compliments from people who say that they're glad you use light-on-dark? 1. http://graphicdesign.stackexchange.com/questions/15142/which-is-easier-on-the-eyes-dark-on-light-or-light-on-dark http://graphicdesign.stackexchange.com/questions/15142/which...
- silon7 11y ago
- cdcarter 11y agoThe design is very much just a spruced version of the Io website that I remember from 2008. Not super fancy, not super verbose, much like the language itself.
- smt88 11y agoI also considered whether the website reflects the language itself. If it does, I wouldn't want to use the language, because it seems to prioritize faux-simplicity and having a unique design over usability. Thankfully, the website creator seems to be actively reading our feedback and interacting with us as users, which makes me think the language itself is probably developed with the same pragmatism, humility, and curiosity. Those are all great characteristics for someone designing a language!
- throwaway1 11y agoYou're clearly an expert on humility.
- dang 11y agoNo personal attacks, please.
- slewis 11y agoCounter argument. Usability does not have to be number one. There are lots of programming languages out there. What if one had a unique take on a website? It's healthy for people to try new takes on things. I laud the approach. I think it looks cool and on first glance makes me think, "wow, this doesn't look like it was made by engineers who only think practically, maybe I'll go further to see if there are some unique ideas in the language itself". In other words, don't speak like there is only one true way to do things, especially when you're critiquing someone else's work. (this last statement is slightly in jest as I'm doing the same to you!)
- brianmurphy 11y agoBikeshedding - if they can't make a website, how are they supposed to make a good programming language?
- smt88 11y agoI agree that language design isn't related to website design. However, how widely-used a language is matters a lot to me. I'd wager that it matters a lot to most people. And a language's user base is definitely affected by its website design. How much is it affected? I really don't know.
- smt88 11y ago> In other words, don't speak like there is only one true way to do things You're absolutely right. I made some assumptions and let my own values come through. My assumptions are 1) that this developer wants his/her language to succeed, 2) that a language succeeds because it's usable/accessible, and 3) that this design is not usable/accessible. #2 and #3 are totally debatable, which is why I told OP not to take my word for it and to observe users instead. I'm just one user, and not an expert or designer.
- drewm1980 11y agoI agree; I came back here to read comments to get some idea what the language is all about. He/She could have just babbled a little about what makes their language special in a static html page with zero formatting, and included a github link, and it would be more effective.
- babo 11y agoThe about page is just a click away. On your third visit that part would be irrelevant, I prefer to put it in a separate page.
- galfarragem 11y agoCompletely agree. Nice website examples for general purpose programming languages IMO: http://www.scala-lang.org/ http://www.scala-lang.org/ https://www.haskell.org/ https://www.haskell.org/ http://www.gnu.org/software/guile/ http://www.gnu.org/software/guile/ For altJS languages: http://coffeescript.org/ http://coffeescript.org/ EDIT: Some websites that could be 'freshened up': http://elixir-lang.org/ http://elixir-lang.org/ http://elm-lang.org/ http://elm-lang.org/ https://www.python.org/ https://www.python.org/ Some websites that definitely should be 'freshened up': http://clojure.org/ http://clojure.org/ http://www.lua.org/ http://www.lua.org/
- swah 11y agoTo be fair the old website was perfectly in sync with the io idea.