3 ms·
> the risk of these salmon escaping to the wild doesn't sound particularly dangerous to me. It should. You can think of a GM species as akin to introduce a for
by munificent 11y ago
> the risk of these salmon escaping to the wild doesn't sound particularly dangerous to me.
It should. You can think of a GM species as akin to introduce a foreign species to a new environment. Except in this case, instead of coming from some other continent, it came from a lab.
So, how does introducing foreign species go? Often, it's fine. But often, it's catastrophically destructive.
Think kudzu in the Southeast, rabbits and cane toads in Australia, killer bees, carp in the Mississippi, and rats pretty much everywhere they've been introduced.
A new, aggressive species that the ecosystem hasn't had time to get used to can decimate an area and cause species to go extinct before they have time to adapt.
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoExcept these are sterile females, farmed in inland pools[1]. I agree in general that we should consider the possibility of GM species interbreeding with or out-competing existing species, but this case seems exceptionally safe. 1: http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2015/11/genetically_engineered_aquabounty_salmon_safe_fda_decides.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/201...
- enraged_camel 11y agoThe risk of this GM species escaping into the environment is infinitesimally small. http://arstechnica.com/science/2015/11/fda-approves-first-gmo-food-animal-atlantic-salmon/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2015/11/fda-approves-first-gm... Key part: "The agency also assessed potential environmental effects and the proposed containment method. In accordance with the FDA’s approval, the fish must be kept in inland tanks, specifically tanks at two facilities—one in Canada and the other in Panama. The Canadian facility will keep the breeding stock, and the Panama site will be used to raise the fish to market-size. Both facilities have multiple, redundant physical barriers to keep the fish and eggs from escaping, the agency noted. Tanks have covers, nets, jump fences, covered drains, and closed septic systems. In addition, conditions of natural water systems surrounding the Panama site, particularly the warm temperatures, are expected to be lethal to the salmon. The Panama site will raise all-female, sterile fish."