5 ms·
LEO by far isn't the most difficult part, not if you are aiming for moon/inter-planetary transport. LEO is ridiculously easy to get too, The ISS is at 340KM, GE
by dogma1138 11y ago
LEO by far isn't the most difficult part, not if you are aiming for moon/inter-planetary transport.
LEO is ridiculously easy to get too, The ISS is at 340KM, GEO orbit is 35,000 you can put payload in LEO with "amateur" rockets, GEO/HEO is a completely different story, it's extremely hard and you need a heck of a rocket to do it with any substantial payload.
Now from GEO/HEO to anywhere else it's quite easy to get because you are pretty much near the escape velocity so it takes almost no delta-v to get pretty much anywhere you want in the solar system, at least as far as getting to a higher solar orbit goes as the closer you get the faster your solar orbital velocity is so using that speed to get even to the edges of the solar system takes very little energy.
If we talk about say a mars shot then most of the energy in that trip goes to 2 things, getting to high earth orbit, and then slowing down for a mars capture the amount of fuel needed to do the martian orbit transfer is almost negligible.
- mikeash 11y agoWhat amateur rockets can put payload into LEO?
- dogma1138 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Space_eXploration_Team https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Space_eXploration_Tea... Their "go fast rocket" got to about half the altitude of Sputnik so if you got the cash you don't need to scale "go fast rocket" up by that much to put a cube-sat / micro-satellite up there.
- fivesigma 11y agoThe difference between such a ballistic trajectory (1/5th of escape velocity) and LEO is huge. >you don't need to scale "go fast rocket" up by that much My napkin math says you need at least 2 orders of magnitude more fuel mass which classifies as "a lot"
- dogma1138 11y agoNot sure what your math is, but mine is about 20% larger rocket to get to 160KM and have enough speed for orbit, at least as far as cube-sats that can skip on the atmosphere for a bit go. There's also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copenhagen_Suborbitals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copenhagen_Suborbitals with their plans for a manned suborbital flight, their rocket (although it blew up) could also be used as a base for amateur orbital flights. I'm not entirely sure what is so surprising here, it's a question of money at this point, but amateur rockets are quick close to being able to reach space, this doesn't mean that they will be commercial viable or even viable for any non-anecdotal use.
- avmich 11y agoLEO difficulty is mostly speed, not height. SpaceShipOne flew above 100 km - but it's a long way to reach Vostok-1 performance, as delta-V for SS1 is more than four times less than for Vostok-1.
- mikeash 11y agoWhat's surprising is that amateur rockets can reach space on suborbital trajectories but none of them come even remotely close to orbit. Altitude is the easy part, relatively speaking. Getting the speed for LEO is the hard part. The GoFast rocket you linked to has demonstrated up to 4,200MPH. Low earth orbit requires about 17,000MPH. That factor of ~4 requires massively larger rockets, because the rocket equation is cruel. Each incremental increase in final speed requires an exponential (actually using this word correctly, for once) increase in the amount of fuel. Fuel in return requires more hardware like tanks and engines, which means yet more fuel is required, etc. Edit: using RP-1 as the fuel in a single stage, getting to 4,200MPH requires that 45% of your total rocket mass be fuel at launch. Getting to LEO requires 94% of the mass to be fuel.
- dogma1138 11y agoYes I understand it quite well, ~20% scale up which is 20% longer, and 20% wider is quite a big change in mass. The big problem is either staging or being able to shift it to a shallow enough trajectory and get enough velocity, but it might be solvable if you can do a zoom climb type launch from an aircraft similar to how Pegasus/SpaceShip One do it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(rocket) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(rocket)
- Gravityloss 11y agoIt only takes 2 km/s to get to 100 km altitude on a ballistic hop. But the gravity pulls you down. It takes a 8 km/s horizontal velocity just to stay in orbit. That is in addition to the 2 km/s to just get to the right altitude. So just by speed ratios orbit is 5x the difficulty of a space hop. In reality rocket scaling is exponential (you need more fuel to carry more fuel...) Anyway, I do think nowadays "amateurs" actually could build orbital rockets with budgets in the low millions class. Modern electronics and GPS make it a bit easier than a few decades ago.
- idlewords 11y agoGPS receivers have US-government mandated speed and altitude cutoffs to prevent this scenario. A nice writeup on bypassing them is here: http://www.wired.com/2013/09/bypassin-us-gps-limits-for-active-guided-rockets/ http://www.wired.com/2013/09/bypassin-us-gps-limits-for-acti...
- sbierwagen 11y agoUS-government mandated GPS receivers "capable of providing navigation information at speeds in excess of 600 m/s" are actually covered under the Missile Technology Control Regime. (category II 11.A.3.b.1) http://www.mtcr.info/english/MTCR-April2011-Technical-Annex.pdf http://www.mtcr.info/english/MTCR-April2011-Technical-Annex.... The MTCR has 34 members, basically the G20 minus China and India. Since the MTCR doesn't have any provisions for enforcement, (It's "an informal and voluntary partnership") its US equivalent is the International Traffic In Arms Regulations Act. (Category XV, Section c, if you want to read how the US statute words it. In imperial units, of course, just to make things simple.)
- rory096 11y agoHere's a great graphic on delta-v needed to get all over the solar system (including various orbits), by the way. https://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png https://i.imgur.com/SqdzxzF.png
- rbanffy 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jccooper 11y agoThe concept of LEO being "ridiculously easy to get too" is mad. No amateur rocket has made orbit or even come close. The difficulty of building a vehicle to make LEO is not comparable to building one to raise altitude once in orbit. LEO to GEO is less than half the delta-v of surface to LEO. It is routinely done by satellites alone. The only reason getting to GEO is particularly hard is because you have to get to LEO first. You are right about transfer to Mars, though.