5 ms·
An idea for testing "obviousness" that I find "obvious" but haven't seen suggested elsewhere: require patents to include a "problem statement" that motivated th
by gojomo 19y ago
An idea for testing "obviousness" that I find "obvious" but haven't seen suggested elsewhere: require patents to include a "problem statement" that motivated the invention and sets requirements for a solution.
If the patent's obviousness then gets called into question, find a small panel (3-5) of 'average' software designers, unfamiliar with the patent (perhaps new graduates?) and show them the problem statement. If they come up with an equivalent or better solution in a meager amount of time, the 'invention' didn't add a lot of innovation/value.