2 ms·
Let's calibrate cynical: More or less cynical than justifying surveillance or working with the FBI?
by Zigurd 11y ago
Let's calibrate cynical: More or less cynical than justifying surveillance or working with the FBI?
- tptacek 11y agoLess cynical than those things (you're taking about CMU here, right?) They're not, like, supervillains.
- Zigurd 11y agoDid I call the EFF superheros? And my question about the FBI was more-general. In light of their use of informants against political dissidence, among other problems with their methods, is it even ethical, never mind cynical, to work with the FBI?
- tptacek 11y agoI don't think I would ever work with the FBI. I had to think about it for a second, because, obviously, there are a lot of crimes that the DOJ works on that we can all agree they should be attacking. But the kinds of crimes where they can most use the kind of help I can provide are the ones I'm least comfortable with them working on. When I was much younger (in my late teens), I worked with prosecutors on a case in Seattle --- pro bono, not for money. It was such a bad experience that I wound up going on strike until they sent me a written apology. All the stories I've ever heard about security people collaborating with prosecutors or the FBI or USSS have been horror stories. Later: I should add that I don't grant the premise that the FBI uses informants to crack down on political dissidents --- the Hoover-era FBI surely did, but then, the FBI was not the worst part of the politics of the late 60s.
- Zigurd 11y agoIt sounds like the EFF is rather weakly cynical, if at all, compared to an FBI that now runs a network of 15,000 poor schlubs who have been bought or blackmailed into being the kind of informant network a Soviet-bloc state security outfit would build. We're very lucky to have the EFF.
- tptacek 11y agoIf you want to win arguments this way, do it stylishly; tell us we're lucky to have EFF because at least they're not Aum Shinrikyo. EFF does some good things, and some things I think are less good. I think we're luckier to have the ACLU.
- Zigurd 11y agoTo be fair, Aum is the useful exception that proves the rule about WMDs and non-state actors. After all their efforts, they would have been more deadly with lo-cost improvised explosives. So that's something