6 ms·
There's so much hysteria over toy flying helicopters which I hesitate to call drones, I don't get it. If an airplane did hit a drone would it really be worse th
by donatj 11y ago
There's so much hysteria over toy flying helicopters which I hesitate to call drones, I don't get it. If an airplane did hit a drone would it really be worse than say a goose? Except for the very large professional ones, they're very light and mostly plastic.
Mythbusters more or less proved the consumer models are basically harmless to humans and couldn't break the skin.
As always something new comes along and people are terrified. It's our stupid nature.
- tomswartz07 11y agoThe propellers can absolutely break skin. A commercial quadcopter motor typically runs at 1000KV, meaning that it spins at 1000 RPM per Volt. Most batteries are 12-14 volts. Even for little plastic bits, if they're spinning at 12,000RPM, theres a lot of kinetic energy behind them.
- mattlutze 11y agoThere was, ironically, a MythBusters episode[0] on last night in which they were flying quadcopter drones into dummy torsos (complete with major neck arteries) to see what happened. I'll admit I was surprised to see that, indeed, they were able to puncture through that poor soul's ballistic gel neck and sever the "aorta." 0: http://www.discovery.com/tv-shows/mythbusters/videos/drone-decapitation-high-speed/ http://www.discovery.com/tv-shows/mythbusters/videos/drone-d...
- smackfu 11y ago>Mythbusters more or less proved the consumer models are basically harmless to humans and couldn't break the skin. They only "proved" it couldn't break the skin. They didn't prove it was harmless... if one slams into your head, you're going to be on the ground.
- donatj 11y agoWhat's the terminal velocity and mass of one of these things? I'd like to see the math on this for the actual force such a thing would induce.
- Zikes 11y agoWith the amount of battery power required to keep them in the air for a reasonable length of time, I've often heard them described as "flying cinder blocks". Often the injury concerns come not from propeller blade cuts, but a lithium battery getting dropped on someone's head from 200ft when it loses charge unexpectedly.
- tomswartz07 11y agoReally it depends on the frame. I have a $50 UDI U818A and (with the plastic frame) if I cut the power, it falls no faster than a leaf. It actually does the same 'wobble' and lands softly on the ground. Larger multicopters, like the DJI ones in the article, are much heavier. About 5lbs or so. They fall fast and hard.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI think the primary danger of drones is distraction. Distracting a pilot flying a plane with hundreds of people on-board is not to be treated lightly. (A secondary issue would be a drone getting sucked into plane's engine intake. I don't know if it would break the engine, but it would definitely take away some of it's extremely expensive life time.) As for us pedestrians, a cheap drone with plastic rotor blades (it's a different with carbon fiber; I've heard of cases where old-school RC helicopters chopped off fingers) may not damage me on impact, but getting near-missed by a fast-moving, loud and non-ballistic object can freak one out, making one drop stuff they're carrying, fall off one's bike or run into traffic. And speaking of traffic, I wouldn't want to see what happens when you distract a driver with a drone on a busy road.
- pj_mukh 11y agoThey are only a distraction till they become commonplace. Pilots aren't distracted by Geese.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoBut then again, geese behave more predictably than drones and are smarter than pilots of those drones.
- pj_mukh 11y agoGeese have actually taken down planes on various occasions, I don't see the FAA regulating herding techniques around airports. Wait, or do they? I'm not sure.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThere are various means airports employ to get rid of stray birds. Unfortunately, most won't be effective against stray drones. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bird_strike#Countermeasures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bird_strike#Countermeasures