4 ms·
Virtual Planes, Virtual Airports: Inside the World of VATSIM
- carlosdp 11y agoThe VATSIM community is awesome. They're so dedicated to following real world operating procedures and realism, I learned so much about aviation doing ATC on the platform when I was in highschool.
- _chris_ 11y ago"The other thing I know is forbidden seems far more innocuous. You’re not allowed to say “roger”." Huh? Roger and Wilco are said all the time in real life (obviously not an appropriate response to all ATC requests, but far from forbidden).
- naz 11y agoMaybe they have "roger" confused with "copy", which is widely used but incorrect.
- mikeash 11y agoWhat's incorrect about "copy"?
- clamprecht 11y agoThe thing that you never say in aviation radio communications is "10-4". That's for CB. Roger, wilco, "no joy", and "tally ho" are used all the time. No joy means "I don't see the traffic you just told me about", and "tally ho" means "I see the traffic." This guy has a bunch of videos that are pretty good for radio comms: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCxGjm4p2paQEhuyuVp_woDA https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCxGjm4p2paQEhuyuVp_woDA
- naz 11y agoThanks for the video. I did my PPL in the UK so coming to America was a bit of a radio culture shock. I think "looking for traffic" and "traffic in sight" are the ICAO phraseology, and will work everywhere. Flying to France, you might confuse a French controller by saying "tally ho". Having thought about it some more, the statement about "roger" not being allowed was probably missing some context. He probably meant it in the context of an ATC instruction that requires reading back.
- bisrig 11y agoI think the author got a bit confused, as the next paragraph (quoting the VATSIM ATC) clarifies this statement... in the example given the ATC instruction requires readback. "Roger" is not what the controller is looking for in that case.
- erpellan 11y agoDo they have any problem with controllers directing planes into the ground or pilots deliberately crashing? Most of my flight sims ended that way after I got bored.
- jacquesm 11y agoWe've had both those problems IRL I'd imagine they have them in a simulated environment too.
- hn_user2 11y agoATC access is tightly controlled and requires work to get. Don't have this problem with controllers. The pilots taking the time to go through VATSIM are also the ones taking the time to do things right. They almost always finish their trips. When they don't, they usually let the controllers know.
- jkaljundi 11y agoThere is now also a very good paid service called Pilotedge: https://www.pilotedge.net/ https://www.pilotedge.net/
- david-given 11y ago> ...when you’re approaching an airport and an air traffic controller is giving you your initial clearance, he’s going to tell you where he wants you, what altitude he wants you at, what speed he wants you at, what heading he wants you on, until you intercept the localiser for the runway you’re going to land on. So he’s going to give you about six pieces of information in a single sentence. You need to be ready to accept that information and understand it. If you’re not it’s going to come at you like arglebargle and you’re going to be saying please repeat please repeat please repeat. Well he doesn’t have time to do that because there may be fifteen aircraft in the pattern so please repeat is an extraordinary request in many circumstances. Why isn't this information transmitted digitally? Fire it off in a sideband of the radio transmission, or even just as a half-second modem bleep in the audio track. You keep the voice communication for redundancy and backwards compatibility for planes that don't have the equipment, but having the information actually appear on your console is surely highly desirable? ...actually, isn't this technology already available, so that ATC can give commands to planes flying on full autopilot?
- akira2501 11y ago> You keep the voice communication for redundancy and backwards compatibility for planes that don't have the equipment, but having the information actually appear on your console is surely highly desirable? Are you _absolutely_ certain you can prevent unauthorized use of this channel? Keep in mind what you're proposing is that hundreds of semi-independent agencies have the ability to push this information directly into the aircraft FMC. The other reason it's communicated this way is because over an open audio channel other pilots can listen to the traffic and keep themselves apprised of situations in the local airspace and advise of conflicts with previous instructions. Finally, it leaves the choice in the hands of the pilot. The controller may give incompatible instructions (runway not long enough for landing weight) or make impossible guidance requests (airspeed too low for landing configuration). The FMC is not a friendly computer system to use and it is highly integrated with most of the critical flight systems. It most certainly isn't perfect and pilots absolutely do not want anyone to be able to make changes to their flight data remotely. > ...actually, isn't this technology already available, so that ATC can give commands to planes flying on full autopilot? Nope. No one is particularly interested in developing it either.