6 ms·
My conjecture on why it works (for non-SAD cases of depression): People who are depressed are likely socially isolated (by choice, perhaps because of depression
by Jtsummers 11y ago
My conjecture on why it works (for non-SAD cases of depression): People who are depressed are likely socially isolated (by choice, perhaps because of depression, or by circumstances, perhaps causing depression) and also physically isolated in homes or offices without good natural sunlight (again, the physical isolation may be a consequence of depression and wanting to be alone, or causal). I've spent several hours a day outdoors or in buildings (mainly a gym) with large windows providing lots of natural sunlight this year. I'm also in the best mood I've been in years. Of course, two factors have changed here for me: more light, more physical activity. Both are correlated with improving mood for people with depression, so I can't say which has had the greater effect for me.
- snewk 11y agoa well balanced diet helps alleviate depression too. too many weeks of staying cooped up in the basement eating pizza rolls will take its toll both physically and mentally
- Jtsummers 11y agoShould've mentioned that. I guess I made three major changes this year (my previous diet wasn't bad, but too large portion sizes).
- dfc 11y agoI have heard this from a couple of people but I have never seen any studies to support this folk-medicine remedy for clinical depression. Do you have any literature pointers?
- astrange 11y agoWell, pizza rolls in the basement have a terrible ratio of omega-3/omega-6 and no vitamin D, and omega-3 supplementation is quite effective against depression. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21939614 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21939614 So there ya go.
- dfc 11y agoThat is for one supplement or for "a balanced diet"? Because the way I read that it seems I could eat whatever and take the fish oil supplement.
- astrange 11y agoSure, why not? You could always eat your ingredients instead of cooking too.
- dfc 11y agoI am not trying to be rude but I really don't know what you are trying to say. Yes, if I understand the study you linked to, as long as i take the supplement or drizzle fish oil on my pizza I could eat a totally unbalanced diet of raw or cooked ingredients. But your original comment was about "a balanced diet" not the benefits of one very specific supplement?
- astrange 11y agoI didn't make that comment, and I can't immediately provide proof of the health of a regular diet vs a bunch of supplements. But they have a ton of sodium and not much fiber, so if anything you'd get pretty constipated.
- shostack 11y agoHere's my "N=1" anecdote: Not sure if I technically have SAD, but I definitely used to get depressed during winter in Chicago because the sun was NEVER out. Since moving to the Bay Area I've been noticeably happier. Beyond that, I have two full-spectrum lamps at home. I used to use one last year on my desk at home, but haven't used them lately. My desk doesn't get a ton of natural light, so I've considered bringing one to the office since daylight savings makes it SOOO dark. When I'm using the lamp, I experience a similar feeling to when I'm basking in sunlight. I feel like I am gaining energy rather than losing it. Sometimes it can be a bit bright, but the brightness doesn't hurt...it is just energizing. Really hard to explain, and again, sample size of 1 here, but the lamps can help in some cases. When I used it most recently last winter on my desk at night after a long work day, it definitely helped. But I found that it made it more difficult to go to sleep, so instead I don't use it, have f.lux running, and just try to get outside into the natural sunlight when I can for a little bit when I can carve out some free time. I live in California so might as well take advantage of that right?
- superuser2 11y agoIn the northern US states there is basically no reasonable behavior pattern that results in enough sun through the winter. By 4:30pm it's indistinguishable from 10:30pm. Most people's work and school schedules put the bulk of their free time in the afternoon and evening.
- Bluestrike2 11y agoSkiing. The world needs more skiers.