4 ms·
This logic applies to all consumer products. The best way to tell which car is safer is to read the original cash-test reports. Furthermore, if you make a mi
by jessriedel 11y ago
This logic applies to all consumer products.
The best way to tell which car is safer is to read the original cash-test reports. Furthermore, if you make a mistake in choosing your car, there is some chance you'll die as a result. Should we ban car commercial? Even car commercials that merely report (as they usually do) summaries of the crash-test reports ("best is class safety!", "4 stars from the car insurance safety board!"), because they may be biased in how they do so?
- phren0logy 11y agoCars are not only available by prescription.
- jessriedel 11y agoSo? You've identified a difference between cars and drugs, but it's not one that prevents your argument from applying to cars.
- woodman 11y agoVehicles are though, by way of DOT standards, various state regulations and licences... Wanna drive on the highway? That better be a vehicle perscribed for such activity.
- jerf 11y agoCars are already heavily regulated. The minimum-legal car may not be comfortable and may not be pretty, but it'll be pretty darned safe and be decently efficient (considering the amount of material it is hauling around to be that safe). You can't advertise a death trap because it's already illegal to sell one. It's a poor comparison to the medical world where you can not help but do dangerous things to solve even more dangerous problems.
- jessriedel 11y agoYou are vastly more likely to die in a car crash than from a non-abused prescription drug. Furthermore, small cars are significantly more deadly than large ones and trucks. Car companies obscure this by comparing cars to ones "in their class", thereby misleading the consumer into thinking that their high-scoring small car is about as safe as it gets. (I am putting aside opiate abuse, since illegal use is a different thing and opiates aren't advertised anyway. But this wouldn't much hurt my argument, since the deaths from cars are very comparable to opiate abuse, so one still can't argue that drugs are more dangerous than cars.)
- bcoates 11y agoTrucks? Last I researched this the Ford F150 and Dodge Ram -- popular, mainstream pickup trucks -- were by a large margin statistically among the least safe vehicles allowed on roads in America, compared across everything, not just in-class.
- jessriedel 11y agoDoesn't really matter to my argument, but for fun: In general, heavier vehicles are vastly safer. If you raise the center-of-gravity off the ground a lot, and don't increase the weight much, it's probably possible to increase the roll-over risk enough to make you worse off. But if you look at the data, you see that the deadliest vehicles are mostly compacts, and the safest ones are mostly SUVs. http://www.thecarconnection.com/news/1096667_the-most-deadly-and-least-deadly-cars-in-america http://www.thecarconnection.com/news/1096667_the-most-deadly... These differences are huge, like, factor of 100 huge.
- whyaduck 11y agoThe numbers in that article (fatalities per vehicle model over a year) aren't terribly useful - fatalities per vehicle mile would have more value. In the end, though, there's little doubt that the U.S. roads are the host of a vehicle size arms race - build in as many safety features as you like, a sub-compact car will still lose the inertia battle with a massive SUV (likely carrying a single passenger).
- bcoates 11y agoApparently I'm out of date -- SUVs and Pickups stopped dominating the death rates in the mid-2000s. Still, the fourfold decrease in fatality rates across the ten model-years the IIHS publishes (coinciding with a substantial increase in the share of vehicle-years for 'mini' sized vehicles) completely discredits the "balance of mass" theory of car fatalities. The stats that article links say that the 2011 mini cooper has driver fatality numbers that would have made it among the safest cars on the road in 2002. Eyeball regression says newer and pricier can explain essentially all of the safety differences, and vehicle size is at best a distant third. http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/driver-death-rates http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/driver-death-rates