3 ms·
Summary of answer from both common sense and the article: Yes. I suspect the answer would be the same if the question were simply "do good manners matter?", but
by sanderjd 11y ago
Summary of answer from both common sense and the article: Yes. I suspect the answer would be the same if the question were simply "do good manners matter?", but that is probably much harder to study. This is not meant to diminish the study; confirming seemingly obvious things is important.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoIt's not necessarily an obvious conclusion. Many people look at the success of Linux and of Apple under Steve Jobs and conclude that a rude leader is a positive.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoOne wildly successful rude leader gets thousands of times more attention and consideration than the thousands of amiable managers who do their jobs well without hurting people's feelings.
- hueving 11y agoIn both the case of Linus and Jobs, they aren't/weren't reviewing everyone's code directly. It's possible to work on Linux and work at Apple without enduring the wrath of the very top.
- sanderjd 11y agoWell those people are obviously wrong :). Joking aside, point taken. One of the reasons it is important to confirm "obvious" things is that one person's "obvious" is another person's "clearly wrong". I will say that I think the reason the "rudeness as a positive leadership trait" thing gets so much attention is because most people expect it to not be the case. Non-intuitive things tend to make for better stories.