4 ms·
Presumably there's a large amount of people undecided or unopinionated about these topics, being browbeaten by the telescreen. It can't all be sociological nor
by mindslight 11y ago
Presumably there's a large amount of people undecided or unopinionated about these topics, being browbeaten by the telescreen.
It can't all be sociological normalization, can it?
- rayiner 11y agoI think very few people are undecided about these things. These are "gut feeling" judgments. What is the appropriate trade-off between security and freedom? What is an acceptable amount of immigration and how much should we require people to integrate? Nobody sits there and does a cost-benefit utilitarian analysis of those questions, if one was even possible. They start with broad principles (e.g. surveillance is per se bad) and interpret facts to fit into their preconceptions.
- noobermin 11y agoHonest question, people say this a lot, but why do we just have to do it without resisting it? I'd hope that the point of education to avoid that kind of reasoning (or lack thereof) as much as possible, not just to give our preconceived notions a tapestry of intellectualism.
- rayiner 11y agoThe fact is that for these sorts of high-level questions, there is no educated answer. There are no double-blind studies you can rely on to come to an educated conclusion. So instead you have people, even educated people, viewing everything through the lens of their chosen principles.
- jessaustin 11y agoThis is a simplification of the issue. If some think surveillance is per se bad, who is it who thinks surveillance is per se good?
- rayiner 11y agoI don't imagine that anyone thinks that surveillance is per se bad, but I'd bet there are lots of people who just see it as a possible option without necessarily assigning a negative reaction to it.
- ionised 11y ago> I don't imagine that anyone thinks that surveillance is per se bad. Really?
- jessaustin 11y agoBased on the rest of the thread, that's probably a typo. It's an interesting slip, however, because he already set up this so-illuminating contrast between a simpleminded "durhh, surveillance bad" straw man and those wise dispassionate thinkers who are willing to consider any state action in its proper context. Because apparently it's necessary to burn the straw, no one is against e.g. the surveillance required on the part of police in order to avoid indiscriminately arresting everyone all the time. I.e., if police have good reason to believe that a law has been broken, it's probably appropriate to make an arrest. If they don't, it's probably not. Some targeted surveillance is appropriate to distinguish those two situations.
- ikeboy 11y agoSome do. The good parts of academia, policy journals, think tanks, etc. But that doesn't get into mainstream media because it's boring. (Whether that stuff affects actual policies undertaken is a good question. I think it does, both directly, I.e. politicians read them, and indirectly by influencing the elite, who influence politicians.) There's also government agencies who make decisions based on public comments, both in law and in policy. There may be other influences, but I think the actual argument do matter somewhat.