3 ms·
The second moment occurred soon after he turned twelve, when he was given “a little book dealing with Euclidean plane geometry.” The book’s “lucidity,” he w
by Jtsummers 11y ago
The second moment occurred soon after he turned twelve, when he
was given “a little book dealing with Euclidean plane
geometry.” The book’s “lucidity,” he wrote—the idea that a
mathematical assertion could “be proved with such certainty
that any doubt appeared to be out of the question”—provoked
“wonder of a totally different nature.”
Mathematical proofs, first really introduced in Geometry classes for most US students around 9th or 10th grade, are what really hooked me on math. I understood everything up to that point (and after), but it was a structural understanding (the rules and syntax, essentially). Once we arrived at logic, I (as a very bored precocious student) spent most of my class time proving everything from the axioms we were given (for algebra or geometry) that I could.
Giving students the tools to play and explore freely (we had proof assignments, of course, but I took it far beyond that) is what really hooks them on a subject. Mandate that they must read these books, they'll hate it. Require them to read a book and a few excerpts of others, and give them access to a large library, and they'll read forever. Same with every other subject. That's where many of the real geniuses[0] of a field come from.
[0] Whether technically geniuses by IQ or just acknowledged as such for their understanding and creations.
- jwdunne 11y agoI notice this learning maths as an adult. A good intro to logic and proofs opened up a new world. After struggling with a proof, I came to the conclusion that I needed to study the axioms I was obviously expected to know futher - most importantly, I wanted to. How did I want to study and understand them? By proof. I remember a similar course with programming, actually. One curiosity led to the next once I equipped myself with the tools to think and experiment with computers.
- Jtsummers 11y agoI will also say, and meant to mention in my original comment, good textbooks are beautiful things. Most textbooks by the time I got to HS (mid-1990s) were meh. And they seemed to be getting worse each year. Compared to the books my parents and previous generations experienced. (Specifically for math.) Older books tended to be small, concise and precise. Think Sipser's automata text, but for everything in math. Being a third generation mathematician certainly helped by providing me access to an older library of books than a lot of my high school and college peers realized were available.
- jwdunne 11y agoThanks for the tip :) I'll explore that. Do you have any recommendations for textbooks to sink my teeth into?
- Jtsummers 11y agoUnfortunately, not much. I was pondering that after my post. It's been a long time since I was a math student, and professionally it's had zero to do with my career. A lot of books ended up boxed up at my parents' home as I moved around a number of times right after college. I'll check my own home tonight to see what I still have, but my shelves these days are mostly filled with fiction, programming, RPG, and history books. EDIT: Off the top of my head, for CS: Introduction to Algorithms: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/introduction-algorithms https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/introduction-algorithms Introduction to the Theory of Computation: http://www.amazon.com/Introduction-Theory-Computation-Michael-Sipser/dp/113318779X http://www.amazon.com/Introduction-Theory-Computation-Michae... Math: Calculus Made Easy: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0312185480?ref_=cm_lmf_tit_5 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0312185480?ref_=cm_lmf_tit_... - I'm really not sure how good this one is for a beginner, I picked it up while assisting my sister in refreshing her calculus skills for grad school (Aerospace Engineering) I can't remember the algebra and geometry textbooks (my dad's or my grandfather's) that I used, in addition to the assigned text, in high school. Anything by Knuth. Seriously, one summer a professor and I just picked up copies of Concrete Mathematics and worked through large portions of it for fun. Technically I got some math credits for it, but it was really just because we wanted to. Actually, this one helped me a lot with understanding calculus. Somehow, up to that point while I knew calculus, may brain had never made the connection that integration was summation until I saw the discrete counterpart to continuous integration. I had a mechanical understanding, but no deep understanding until that moment.
- kirsebaer 11y agoGood ideas, but why "require" any books at all?
- Jtsummers 11y agoThey can be very efficient for conveying information. I'm not a strong fan of videos (as some friends of mine are) as substitutes for texts on a subject. On the same side, lectures aren't enough either. They're all different aspects of the same thing: expressing information to others. If we move away from traditional texts, I like the idea of "smart" books. These would be interactive (where appropriate) in demonstrating concepts or guiding students through exercises (such as a proof or stepping through an algebra problem one step at a time). However, I think in the end (my opinion) good books are irreplaceable as sources of information, and should be aided by lectures, videos, tutoring and interactive apps.