5 ms·
Yes, if the 65816 (or something similar) came out in 1978 (the same year as 8086, 6809 and 68000), we'd probably be in a very different world. In the late 70'
by bryanlarsen 11y ago
Yes, if the 65816 (or something similar) came out in 1978 (the same year as 8086, 6809 and 68000), we'd probably be in a very different world. In the late 70's, the Apple II was the dominant business machine, because it was the best machine to run Visicalc. But in the 80's, Lotus 1-2-3 on PC completely demolished Visicalc, and the IBM PC hegemony began.
Of course, given how badly Apple screwed up the Apple III, it's unlikely even the 65816 could have saved it.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoIt would have been interesting if Atari or Commodore had continued their 8-bit lines on the '816 instead of chasing after the 68k. A 65c816 with Jay Miner's Amiga/Lorraine chipset would have been a natural successor to the Atari 8-bit series. My impression is the Apple IIGS was deliberately handicapped by pressure of the Jobs/Mac partisans at Apple. It could have gone out with a higher clock and been a contender.
- protomyth 11y agoI think the 68000 was a much better architecture than the 65816. It was nicer to program and had 32-bit registers which was probably the result of not really being a ISA compatible successor to either the 6800 or 6809. Perhaps if WDC had built a 32-bit successor to 6502 instead of a 16-bit with some weird performance issues, it would have been more interesting. I do wish something had evolved so we could have something to power the low-end PC market in the original 6052 price range.
- setpatchaddress 11y agoA contender for what, though? As neat as it was (I remember it fondly -- I'd love to buy one for myself now), the IIgs was a distraction and a dead end. The Apple II division had been starved for resources forever, and the IIgs was too little, too late. Just viewing it from a raw computing power perspective: by 1986, it was clear that you needed more than 16-bit addressing capability by the end of the decade.
- EdiX 11y agoHonest question: what exactly do you think is great about the 65816? Because I don't know much about the 65816 but I don't really see the appeal, even compared to the 8086. The 65816 had even less general purpose registers than the 8086, the Direct Page stuff seems like it would be a pain in the ass to use manually and a nightmare for compilers and the instruction set was already saddled with a rather awkwardly implemented backwards compatibility with the 6502 (set this two processor flags and now you are running on a 8bit processor instead of a 16bit one!)
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoFrom what I understand the advantage the 65xx had over the 8008/8080, and Z80 back in the day was a) price and b) way better cycle efficiency and c) faster interrupt response. The 6502 could often do in 1 cycle what a Z80 took 4 cycles to do. An 8-bit memory read or write was 1 cycle. For 8-bit home computers mostly used for graphics and games, that's cool cuz you got good performance per dollar. I guess 65c816 kept that speed and its simplicity and offered an upgrade path. But only the IIGS and the SNES used it. Direct page is pretty cool when you consider that the cost of a memory access was 1 cycle. So it's effectively 256 extra registers (tho still only one ALU).