3 ms·
So here's an interesting question: if you sell fake weapons (or weapons materials) to a terrorist organization as part of a scam, is it illegal? Normally, sell
by mikeash 11y ago
So here's an interesting question: if you sell fake weapons (or weapons materials) to a terrorist organization as part of a scam, is it illegal?
Normally, selling weapons to terrorists would be illegal. But these aren't actually weapons.
And normally, scamming people would be illegal. But you're scamming terrorists trying to carry out an illegal transaction.
I'm sure the answer is, yes, it's illegal. But it's an odd situation and I'm not quite clear as to how it works out.
- talmand 11y agoIt would be fraud, unless the seller believed that it was actually a weapon because intent comes into play. But the victim would have to come forward to file a complaint with a legal authority. Which is possible because there are examples of people going to police after being scammed in a drug deal. I wish it would happen, it would make for an entertaining case.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- steve-howard 11y agoThe last thing I'd be afraid of after selling fake weapons to a brutal terrorist regime would be going to prison for fraud.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI can sort-of imagine the headline. "Man prevented bombings by scamming terrorists, went to jail for tax evasion."
- dragonwriter 11y ago> It would be fraud, unless the seller believed that it was actually a weapon because intent comes into play. But the victim would have to come forward to file a complaint with a legal authority. No, they wouldn't; its not generally mandatory, as a matter of law, for the victim to enter a complaint for criminal prosecution to proceed, though often the government will prefer a complaining and actively cooperative victim, since that both demonstrates that there is a problem to address and makes prosecution easier (since the victim will be an important source of both direct evidence and information that will lead to evidence.)
- talmand 11y agoI understand, but I'm speaking more along the lines that the authorities wouldn't know of the crime in the first place, unless it was reported by the victim. Now, if the government happened to be conducting surveillance on the transaction, then what you describe would come into play.
- Someone1234 11y agoI'd argue yes, simply because many anti-terrorism laws are vaguely enough written to make receiving money from, providing support to, or heck even communicating with (in some circumstances) terrorist organisations can be illegal. Plus then you have wire fraud, regular fraud, and a bunch of other financial crimes. The real question however is not "is it legal," the real question is "will anyone prosecute me?" Jay-walking and speeding are illegal too, but people often do it because they know their chance of being caught and punished is relatively low. If a prosecutor knew you scammed a terrorist organisation, while I'm sure they could find something to nail you with, they might decide it isn't worth while. But then again, misunderstandings seem highly likely with this kind of scam, and they might claim that you yourself thought it was a real explosive device or planned (future tenths) to build one. So I guess, even if you "could" I don't know if you "should." It only can really bite you in the butt.
- billyhoffman 11y agoMarty McFly: Doc, you don't just walk into a store and-and buy plutonium! Did you rip that off? Dr. Emmett Brown: Of course. From a group of Libyan nationalists. They wanted me to build them a bomb, so I took their plutonium and, in turn, gave them a shoddy bomb casing full of used pinball machine parts. Things did not go well for Doc Brown
- mhurron 11y agoThey worked out in the end.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoSo in other words, you can scam terrorists safely if you have a time machine handy.
- mikeash 11y agoWasn't that the moral of that story?
- snowwrestler 11y agoOr was it the beginning? Time travel makes idioms hard.
- mattzito 11y agoIt's still illegal to sell fake drugs, because you're contributing to the facilitation of the crime. I suspect this would be similar.
- eli 11y agoTaking money from someone under intentionally false pretenses is fraud.
- tantalor 11y agoDon't the cops do that in drug/prostitution stings?
- bdamm 11y agoPolice are empowered and sometimes licensed to act against the law in the pursuit of justice. Anyone who has observed police officers running stop signs (lights or not) knows this.
- tantalor 11y agoHow does this work? Is there a specific legal principle in play? Certainly some laws cannot be broken; how do you decide? Looks like these are called "exemptions" and narrowly scoped to specific codes, e.g., "Exemption of Authorized Emergency Vehicles (California)" https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/pubs/vctop/vc/d11/c1/a2/21055 https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/detail/pubs/vctop/vc/d11/c...
- celticninja 11y agoIf you get caught though they would charge you as if you were selling a real explosive.
- at-fates-hands 11y agoYes, still illegal. You could make the same case if you tried to sell someone fake drugs. Not real drugs, right? Scamming someone who's going to something illegal right? http://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/legal-advice/criminal-defense/drug-charges/jail-selling-fake-drugs.htm http://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/legal-advice/criminal-d... At the very least, it's fraud: Taking money from someone under intentionally false pretenses is fraud. (18 USC § 1001.) Under the law, an intentionally and materially false statement relied upon by another constitutes fraud. Intentionally meaning you did so under the condition you knew the weapons were fake and not real. Materially meaning the mis-representation of the guns as real was material to the transaction.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoYes, its illegal. There are plenty of cases where members of organized crime families (stand in for terrorists) have been convicted of illegal activities which harmed other members of the same or different organized crime family. That said, if you do it under the guise of an intelligence operation then its ok apparently. Also you would be bound by jurisdictional laws, so if you did that in international waters I'm guessing you could make a case for it not being an issue. Further, I doubt anyone would try to prosecute you for pulling a fast one on terrorists, but the terrorist organization is by definition one that doesn't respect the rule of law, borders, or individual human rights, so the lack of prosecution would be the least of your worries.