5 ms·
WDC Re-releases Classic 1986 6502/65816 manual “Programming the 65816”
- jacquesm 11y agoThe 65816 is an interesting beast. I used to have a prototype version of this chip somewhere, though after the nth move I have no idea which of the many crates it lives in or if I may have accidentally thrown it out (I seem to have misplaced my heirlooms as well :( ). The reason why this is an interesting chip is because if offers a window on what an 'alternate universe' might have looked like if Motorola and Intel had had a third viable contender when the CPU wars were still in their infancy. Unfortunately the chip never found itself in a machine that was spread out widely enough and with powerful enough hardware that its potential could be seen. And that's a pity because it had some pretty nifty features, the processor that it is easiest to compare to was the 80286.
- protomyth 11y agoThe 65816 was a bit of an odd chip, I remember it was a little bit of a pain to program on the II GS compared to the 6502. It did make it into the Super NES, so it had volume.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoThe biggest problem with the chip from my perspective is that the program counter register is still limited to 16-bits, so requires segmentation of code into 64k chunks. Likewise I believe the 'direct page' (same as the 6502's zero page, but relocatable, like in the 6809) is limited to the first page, the lowest 64k of memory. Unfortunately it's not an architecture for which a C compiler is a natural fit.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoAnother thing is that is interesting is based on what Sophie Wilson has said about the development of ARM it sounds like WDC just didn't really want to participate in the 16/32-bit battle. The 65816 I think was developed at the behest of Woz/Apple, as a sort-of-16-bit successor for the 6502, no more. The multiplexed bus so they could fit in 40-pin DIP, the 8-bit data bus, the 16-bit program counter, all limited the possibility of it ever competing with the 68k or x86 platforms. I'm sure WDC _could_ have developed such a competitor. It's interesting that even now they haven't done so. They still apparently sell millions of dollars of 65xx cores ever year, I don't know why they've never made a truly 16 or 32-bit 6502.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoYes, if the 65816 (or something similar) came out in 1978 (the same year as 8086, 6809 and 68000), we'd probably be in a very different world. In the late 70's, the Apple II was the dominant business machine, because it was the best machine to run Visicalc. But in the 80's, Lotus 1-2-3 on PC completely demolished Visicalc, and the IBM PC hegemony began. Of course, given how badly Apple screwed up the Apple III, it's unlikely even the 65816 could have saved it.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoIt would have been interesting if Atari or Commodore had continued their 8-bit lines on the '816 instead of chasing after the 68k. A 65c816 with Jay Miner's Amiga/Lorraine chipset would have been a natural successor to the Atari 8-bit series. My impression is the Apple IIGS was deliberately handicapped by pressure of the Jobs/Mac partisans at Apple. It could have gone out with a higher clock and been a contender.
- protomyth 11y agoI think the 68000 was a much better architecture than the 65816. It was nicer to program and had 32-bit registers which was probably the result of not really being a ISA compatible successor to either the 6800 or 6809. Perhaps if WDC had built a 32-bit successor to 6502 instead of a 16-bit with some weird performance issues, it would have been more interesting. I do wish something had evolved so we could have something to power the low-end PC market in the original 6052 price range.
- setpatchaddress 11y agoA contender for what, though? As neat as it was (I remember it fondly -- I'd love to buy one for myself now), the IIgs was a distraction and a dead end. The Apple II division had been starved for resources forever, and the IIgs was too little, too late. Just viewing it from a raw computing power perspective: by 1986, it was clear that you needed more than 16-bit addressing capability by the end of the decade.
- EdiX 11y ago
- mrbill 11y agoThe title says "Kindle Version" on Amazon but the only purchase option is a $45 (!) paperback?
- mrbill 11y agoLooks like it's been fixed and the Kindle version is available for $9.99 now.