5 ms·
Isn't theft a crime? Isn't publicly accusing someone of a crime he did not commit a slander? Should all content-mining researches sue Elsevier for slander? I do
by scotty79 11y ago
Isn't theft a crime? Isn't publicly accusing someone of a crime he did not commit a slander? Should all content-mining researches sue Elsevier for slander? I don't see why not.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoNot sure why this is being downvoted. In my personal opinion Elsevier are slandering (actually libelling) researchers here. This could have significant financial implications for the researchers when e.g. grant applications are made.
- JadeNB 11y agoAssuming that this is just a cri de cœur, I agree with it; but assuming that you actually mean it as a legal argument, it's hard to imagine (although IANAL). Otherwise, the "abortion is murder" folks would already have been sued just for that claim. (That's assuming you agree that abortion isn't murder; but your post also assumes, maybe more safely, that one agrees that content mining isn't a crime.)