7 ms·
If this is how Comcast treats its customers, I wonder why anyone would want to pay them to be their customer. Especially a thousand dollars a years. Is this bec
by mcv 11y ago
If this is how Comcast treats its customers, I wonder why anyone would want to pay them to be their customer. Especially a thousand dollars a years. Is this because there's no real competition in the US?
- sleepychu 11y agoThat's my understanding. (No competition that does it any better.)
- misterbwong 11y agoIn many areas of the country, the cable companies basically have localized monopolies on high speed internet. They claim they have competition in DSL and satellite (!!!) but these technologies just can't compete on speed in this day and age, leaving cable as the only viable alternative. From what I gather, this is one of the reasons why Google started Google Fiber.
- throwaway7767 11y agoInteresting. Over here, providers are offering VDSL2, advertised as 100/100Mbit. Given my experience with DSL, that probably means about half that for the average user who is 2-3km from the DSLAM box. That's still pretty respectable. Is noone offering modern DSL in the US?
- therein 11y agoNope, sadly not. Even in San Francisco (which is pretty sad for being the heart of tech) it is cable or legacy DSL. If you are at a building that has an exclusivity agreement with AT&T, you might even end up paying them $50+ a month for 28mbit fiber. (yes, fiber terminates at my door but that's the max speed they offer)
- mirashii 11y agoTo be fair, there is sonic does offer vdsl2 in many parts of the city, over 100Mbit down, albeit a bit less up. There's also webpass for larger buildings which offers almost a gigabit during non-peak times. So SF isn't as dire as you make it sound, though I agree it's behind many other cities.
- knorby 11y agoWell, there is Webpass for some in SF. I pay $60/mo for 100mbits up & down, and some buildings go up to 500mbits. No contracts, and I just hook up to an ethernet jack in my apartment. It is a local startup that is expanding elsewhere.
- dylz 11y agoYep, webpass is greatest thing ever.. and there's also sonic.net and paxio.com and gowaveg.com depending on where you are too.
- therein 11y agoI love WebPass, and I used them exclusively in my previous apartment but this new building has this silly exclusivity agreement and Comcast can't make installations on this building as they somehow managed to make this residential building show up as a business address on Comcast's website. I could get Sonic Fusion FTTN but that's just rebranded AT&T, and peaks at 28mbits. I get better LTE speeds than that. I tried to bring in MonkeyBrains but the building administration refused, saying they would have to drill into load-bearing columns. Just an excuse.
- brbsix 11y agoWebpass is the best Internet service ever. I signed up as soon as our building got it, it was $50/mo then for the 100Mbs. Definitely worth it if you have the opportunity to live in a building that has it. Really straightforward website, billing, and setup. It looks like they're expanding to some other cities. I wish them luck.
- djsumdog 11y agoWhat?! In Cincinnati I had CincyBell Fibre about three years ago. I think I paid around $60 ~ $70. I don't remember the advertised speed, but it was crazy super fast.
- privacy101 11y agoI stay with Comcast because it is way cheaper then AT&T but with AT&T's VDSL I could get 45mbps (fiber to the neighborhood box, apparently).
- kuschku 11y agoVDSL2+, which is rolling out next year, is even supposed to handle 500/200 – in some areas T-Online has been testing it, and supposedly it works (but it means you have to be less than 100m from the box).
- Vendan 11y agoIt varies. If you are in an area with actual competition, they try harder. Where I live, it's crappy TWC 20/5 or so for $60 a month, or a selection of DSL providers offering everything from 5/1 to 0.5 megabits per second for around $20 a month. Seriously, there is an ISP offering a 0.5 Mbps DSL for $20 a month, oh, and it bursts to 1 Mbps...
- onlycommenting 11y agoI wouldn't say there's no competition per se, but some areas are limited based on who has lines out there. For example, the area I live in at Augusta only offers Wow! as a cable provider; over priced reseller. But, I was fortunate enough to land a decent contract- more channels than Wow! and for 1/4 the price- with Dish. Satellite vs. Cable, but I'm willing to take that trade off for a better price point. Plus there's always NetFlix/Hulu.
- ojbyrne 11y agoNot across the entire US, but in many places there are few or zero practical competitors. And where there are competitors, they're most likely AT&T or Time-Warner, which have similar shitty practices.
- chrismbarr 11y agoI live in a small town in Georgia and literally my only internet access options are Comcast and AT&T. AT&T's service here is fairly slow compared to Comcast's offerings, and since I work from home remote for a company based in Florida I have to choose the fastest options available to me, and that's Comcast. I would love to have more options, but I just don't. I only pay for internet access, I don't use their cable TV or telephone offerings. Internet alone is about $80/month. I just ran a speed test and I get 14.1Mbps down & 8.6Mbps up. I forget which speed tier I'm paying for, but I know I'm paying for much more than that! Ugh...
- krisdol 11y agoI live in a large town (Boston) and the situation is not much different.
- colanderman 11y agoIf you're in Boston proper, you can get NetBlazr: http://netblazr.com/ http://netblazr.com/ (wireless mesh network) Unfortunately they don't even reach JP, so I'm stuck with Comcast.
- supermatt 11y agoWhat are your options for satellite internet? The pricing these days seems very competitive, and although latency is (much) higher it should be ideal for the vast majority of use cases.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt looks like they charge the same price for ~1/10 the speed and 1/20 the transfer (Does Comcast still have a 300 GB limit? That compares favorably to 10.)
- mikeash 11y agoLatency is pretty important for browsing the web. No matter how much bandwidth you have, making every request take two round-trips to geosync is going to make the connection feel very slow. If low Earth orbit broadband internet ever happens, that could potentially be an excellent choice. But with the current offerings, it's always going to be the absolute last resort.
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoWhere I am located, it is CenturyLink or Comcast. Neither are any good. AT&T is in the "area", but not MY area. So, that would be 3 bad choices.
- mikeash 11y agoNobody really wants to be a Comcast customer. Comcast thrives because they're mostly the only choice or the less bad choice of two. I was a "happy" Comcast customer for years. I was in a condo where the choices were Comcast or Verizon DSL. Maybe. I called Verizon to see what they had to offer and they didn't know if I could get their DSL service or not. The best they could do was to place an order and see if it worked. Really! Even if I could get service from them, their offer was 1.5Mbps for something like $50/month. Completely ridiculous. It was like this when I moved out about three years ago, and as far as I know it's still like that today.
- brianwawok 11y agoThe only reason I currently use Comcast, is my choices are ATT DSL at 6 mbps, or Comcast. Not that I like ATT, but when (coming in the next 6 months) they roll out faster service, I will be happy to switch.
- Eldarrion 11y agoDon't like ATT either, but at least their service seems to be much more stable. I haven't had to speak with an AT&T customer support rep in over a year. Comcast, I've been doing their trial service run for two weeks now and I've already had to deal with their customer support 6+ times, 2 of which were during the installation. I think I'll probably just end up canceling before my month is up and going back to ATT. At least I knew I could rely on my connection to not crap out at random.
- johnward 11y agoYes. Many markets have literally one option. My options for internet are comcast, or satellite probably? So really my only high speed option is comcast. I don't even think I can get DSL. I think a lot of markets the monopoly is even being protected by law.
- sneak 11y agoIt's like that in a lot of places. I live in extremely central Berlin and cannot find a provider that can deliver above 25mbps for less than hundreds per month. It is a real shame that anything over 5-7mbps is considered "fast enough" by the vast majority of consumers.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- toxican 11y agoTo give you an idea, my internet options are in my area: -Comcast (up to 100MB/s) -Century Link DSL (up to 10MB/s) -3G/4G modem (up to like 3MB/s) Then 10 minutes south of where I live, that county has deals with a local ISP who behaves exactly like Comcast, but with terrible pricing and lower caps. Also no realistic alternatives. While I could stomach the speeds of DSL (with some effort), I can't stomach the price. I'd end up paying just as much as comcast for much lower speeds. I really don't have a choice. edit MB, not mb