3 ms·
The root of this problem is that there is no "control channel" (or whatever you want to call it) from an ISP to its customers. Email doesn't work because ISPs d
by wmf 11y ago
The root of this problem is that there is no "control channel" (or whatever you want to call it) from an ISP to its customers. Email doesn't work because ISPs don't always have the customer's address and email can get spam filtered. Paper mail is expensive and may not be read. Until someone defines and implements a protocol for this, ISPs are going to keep inventing weird kludges. I wonder if Hotspot 2.0 can be adapted for wired networks.
- x1798DE 11y agoAnd yet somehow you get your bill every month?
- zippergz 11y agoIt's probably stupid, but I'll admit I haven't looked at my cable bill for well over a year. I have paperless billing, it auto charges to my credit card, I see that the amount is the same every month, and that's it. If they include any messages with the bill, I never see them. If they sent me something via snail mail I'd probably read it, unless I mistakenly thought it was junk mail and threw it out without looking at it.
- jon-wood 11y agoThe junk mail thing is there own doing. I missed two months of letters from our ISP saying the bill hadn't been processed because I threw them out, assuming it was yet another letter trying to sell me the service I already have.
- simoncion 11y ago> The root of this problem is that there is no "control channel" (or whatever you want to call it) from an ISP to its customers. If it's not important enough to send a note via certified mail, then it's damn well not important enough to MITM my HTTP sessions.
- userbinator 11y agoEmail doesn't work because ISPs don't always have the customer's address What ISPs don't provide an email account (usually something like username@isp-domain) with their service? I thought that was the standard way to do things, and it's what mine does to send me alerts about service outages and maintenance windows.
- elktea 11y agoI've been forced do some awful things with squid and WCCP for this very purpose. A control channel would be great.
- nitrogen 11y agoYou could quit, you know.
- _yy 11y agoWell, most people have email and the ISP can just require that they have a working email address on file. That's how ISPs in Germany do it and it works fine. Or if it's urgent, they'll just call you. No need to invent a new form of communication or do evil things with Squid.
- virtuallynathan 11y agoThis is the root of the problem, and it is being worked on: https://www.caida.org/workshops/aims/1503/slides/aims1503_bauer1.pdf https://www.caida.org/workshops/aims/1503/slides/aims1503_ba...
- mikeash 11y agoPaper mail costs maybe 50 cents for a regular letter. If "may not be read" is a concern, send it certified. That costs all of $4. Too expensive? This is a company that charges $10/month to rent a $50 cable modem. They get none of my sympathy when it comes to cost. If negative sympathy were physically possible, I'd give them that. This problem you describe is solved. Businesses all over the place manage to figure out how to communicate with their customers, but you want me to believe that Comcast is in some impossible situation where their only choice is to corrupt the data they're transmitting? If you need to get in touch with your customers, then you can: 1. E-mail. 2. Call. 3. Send a letter. 4. Send a certified letter. And if none of that works, disconnect the service since there's obviously nobody living there anymore. If the $4 for a certified letter breaks the bank, then add a clause to your service contract that says the customer has to pay it back if it ever gets to that point. Not every problem needs to be solved with computers over the internet.