3 ms·
I don't understand why stock markets function this way. Why don't they work like a Diplomacy game, in turns? Everyone puts their instructions in, then the turn
by stickfigure 11y ago
I don't understand why stock markets function this way. Why don't they work like a Diplomacy game, in turns?
Everyone puts their instructions in, then the turn 'executes' and an algorithm (known to all parties) resolves the actions. Run one turn every second. If you want to buy all 20k shares on offer and nobody else is making the same bid, you get them. Seems reasonably straightforward - what am I missing?
- coderzach 11y agoThe problem is that the current system is just the digital version of a bunch of guys yelling at each other on a trading floor. No one asked what the market should look like, they just took the existing system and computerized it.
- fleitz 11y agoBecause people who trade stock prefer it that way. You're free to setup a market that works in this way, and if consumers prefer it you'll make millions. I'd hazard a guess because the point of markets is to disseminate information and the point of diplomacy is to keep information secret. Seriously, look at it like this, this buyer is a big smart human with a big brain that talks to other humans and likely knows 'secret' information about the company, lets say it's Wal-Mart and he's ordered satelite photos, etc to gauge traffic and knows they are doing well. He has all that information and all the algo knows is 'BUY 20000 @ $4.53' the algo disseminates that information to all the other traders by cancelling its quotes. The buyer pays a premium to gain 83% of the available stock on the market. It's like Mark Cuban and his Yahoo stock, if he dumped it all the day he got it the market would tank because there's more supply than anyone wants, so he wisely instructed his broker to sell over a longer period of time. The buyer could have chose to do this, or he could attempt to buy 83% of the available stock all at once in hopes no one noticed.
- camkego 11y agoThese type systems has been offered for a number of years, it is a good question why they are not more prevalent in the US. http://goo.gl/xXd8So http://goo.gl/xXd8So
- harmegido 11y agoSee my question above for an answer on why they are not more prevalent. If you break ties based on FIFO, you've just created a clunky FIFO match, which is used everywhere. If you break ties randomly, you've just created a clunky pro-rata match, which is used everywhere.
- harmegido 11y agoHow do you resolve the case where there are 20k shares on offer, and two participants each place bids of 20k? Who of the buyers gets filled?
- fleitz 11y agoWhichever order fulfills the rules of the jurisdiction the exchange resides in, I believe in the US that would mean the order that came in first. In general orders are serialized first and then processed according to the order that was serialized, it's impossible to reason about an order book with out serializing entries to it.
- stickfigure 11y agoIt's quite easy to come up with good rules that resolve orders without serialization, and certainly without FIFO serialization. There are a number of strategies that could be employed, including "fractional allocation" and "pick randomly". I doubt it really matters exactly what you pick as long as 1) the rules are applied evenly and 2) everyone thinks they are fair. "My ethernet cable is 5m shorter than your ethernet cable" is does not sound like a reasonable input to the fairness function.
- fleitz 11y agoIt's easily mitigated by submitting your order 16 nanoseconds sooner. Imagine UPS complained to the Feds that FedEx had an unfair advantage because they bought faster planes... And actually it isn't very easy because nothing travels faster than light so you need some ridiculous method to determine with nanosecond accuracy the time that each order was 'created' at, which will invariably lead to people 'creating' orders and then not sending them. Also the entire reason why LMAX is such a great method is because it IS serialized and IS FIFO doing those two things allows 6 million tps. It's like seeing a car on the lot announcing I will pay $18,000 for this car and then wondering why the dealer won't sell for less than $18,000. There's no law that says you have to trade on exchanges with HFT, you can trade on exchanges that don't allow HFT, have fun trying to find a counterparty though. Markets aren't fair they are efficient. With enough money you can destroy practically any company. Don't like the cut of someone's jib? Buy any debt linked to stock price, short the fuck out of it then call it, leak a story about the outstanding debt and then profit on your short, buy more debt and force bankruptcy as the senior lender.