3 ms·
Except encryption provides a level of privacy that has never before been possible. Could you imagine a physical padlock that was unable to be cracked, cut, or
by slg 11y ago
Except encryption provides a level of privacy that has never before been possible. Could you imagine a physical padlock that was unable to be cracked, cut, or circumvented in any way? It is easy to see how that would scare law enforcement. Imagine your job is to keep people safe. Now envision a kid strapped to a bomb inside a shack and the only thing preventing you from breaking in and saving that kid's life is that magical and unbreakable padlock. That is how many laypeople view encryption. It is hard to tell that person that you won't consider introducing any weakness into that lock.
- lholden 11y agoBut those are not the same thing. Encryption in this case would be like the location of the kid and bomb being kept secret. The bad guy may have told someone in person where the location is... or sent an encrypted email. But unless you were involved in either conversation, you are still in the dark.
- richdougherty 11y agoThat's a good analogy, but the padlock has already bolted! Information about the uncrackable padlock is widely available. Bad guys will always be able to get these padlocks from the black market. The question is whether we want the good guys (i.e. us) to have the padlocks too.
- slg 11y agoThis is a fair counter, but I feel like we already have examples of how the government would respond there. We might have to switch analogies, but wouldn't encryption then be like a weapon. The goal would then shift to being about deproliferation. The fact that nuclear weapons or AK47s already exist doesn't prevent the government from preventing regular people from acquiring or using them. Maybe preventing new products from entering the market and flooding the market with faulty products (encryption with backdoors) is a good way of combating what is already out there.
- dplgk 11y agoThe terrorists will use encrypted, unbreakable methods no matter that Google or Apple use is their OS. That's really the only point that matters.
- slg 11y agoAnd I might be able to get my hands on an AK47 if I really wanted and had enough money to dedicate to it. That is the truth of the world. But do you believe that making it harder to acquire a weapon like that doesn't have some benefit? Back to HN's world, one of the basic principles of human factors is "make the right thing easy and the wrong thing hard." You might not be able to prevent people from doing the wrong thing, but there is still value in making it harder to do.
- dplgk 11y agoIt's not hard to download some software while sitting in your house. Much easier than buying an illegal gun.
- richdougherty 11y agoI don't think non-proliferation would be a good idea for encryption technology: 1. Depriving the the public of decent encryption does a lot of harm. If you let some people in through the backdoor you're going to let bad people in too. This is different from nuclear bombs. It doesn't harm the public to deprive them of nuclear weapons. I like having my financial information encrypted, but I don't want a personal nuclear bomb. 2. Non-proliferation of encryption wouldn't work. The algorithms and ideas are already widespread. Every university teaches it. Millions of computers have the code already. The code and ideas can be proliferated anonymously, instantly, undetectably and cheaply. This is different from nuclear bombs. Nuclear bombs are much more complex and expensive to transport, manufacture and hide. (I haven't mentioned AK47s, but I'd say they fall somewhere between between encryption and nuclear bombs in benefit vs harm to the public and in ease vs difficulty of non-proliferation, which is why there are more of them around than there are nuclear bombs.)
- 11y ago
- giaour 11y agoExcept the government also has stuff it needs to keep secret, so they have a vested interest in unbreakable padlocks existing. So they want a skeleton key for all civilian padlocks, but they will continue to use magic padlocks. That requires journals on padlock research, which probably won't themselves be kept behind magic padlocks. Clever locksmiths will always be able to make powerful padlocks using that research.
- serge2k 11y ago>Except encryption provides a level of privacy that has never before been possible Not really. It secures long distance communication, but I've always had the option of just talking to someone privately if I want something to be secret.