3 ms·
Race and Merit at MIT
- hga 17y agoOutside of fields like "music, theater and writing", the ones MIT is really serious about, it's only fair to hire the very best. In those fields, at MIT you don't get tenure unless you are #1 or 2 in your sub-field (sometimes maybe but very rarely #3). "Furthermore, it is clear that the value placed on gaining a diverse faculty is not high." Damned straight: "the very best in their fields" has nothing to do with a "diverse faculty" as defined in this study. Anyway, we're talking about pretty small numbers here. MIT has 1,003 faculty members, I don't think any departments are significantly/disproportionately larger than say the "average" (MIT has a strong policy of not letting the facility and graduate program of a department get too large because fields tend to go bust, witness aero/astro in the early '70s, nuclear engineering a little later, and EECS at the beginning of this decade; in the sciences physics has seriously declined and chemistry is smaller than it used to be). So you have to be very careful about drawing conclusions. See the comment by Jack Olson: for many departments the pool of black scholars is nonexistent. Bottom line of the report, as summarized in this article: MIT may be imperfect in its pursuit of its ideal of meritocracy, and discussion of meritocracy along the axis of "diversity" is discouraged at best. My comment: Too bad, if you want to play the academic game by different rules, the majority of universities and colleges in the US will be delighted to accommodate you. MIT will never do so. Or as commentator "mb" put it, "There is no such thing as 'black thermodynamics,' 'women's calculus,' [or] 'hispanic quantum mechanics'".
- patio11 17y agoAffirmative action also creates distortions in the pipeline for new hirees. For example, since essentially all private elite universities in the United States systematically discriminate on the basis of race, for a given "quality" of applicant, minority applicants are likely to have a more prestigious degree. This tends to concentrate the top-of-the-field scholars MIT wants to attract at a very, small set of institutions, since if you move just a little down the institutional prestige scale you'll find schools happily admitting minority students who are not cut out for careers at world-class research institutions. This is difficult to verify because universities lie pervasively about their systematic racial discrimination, but when data does come to light about them, for example in the Gratz v Bollinger litigation, it typically shows that the discrimination is less a "plus factor" and more "two institutions at different academic tiers which happen to be geographically co-located". (The difference between the mean white and black student at the University of Michigan is more than the difference between the mean UoM student and the mean Harvard student.)
- hga 17y agoThomas Sowell has written extensively about this, using his alma mater of Harvard. Using MIT as an example: If you come across a minority MIT undergraduate, it's an absolutely safe assumption they belong there. With one notable exception (Dean of Students Shirley McBay, who just didn't have the right attitudes for that job), that was also my experience with the staff (probably goes along with the general attitude of meritocracy). MIT is currently getting around 13,000 applicants each year with a third of them being qualified to attend (self-selection by applicants is very strong). I would assume that MIT accepts pretty much every qualified STEM minority applicant (although I'm sure a lot go elsewhere; predicting yield is probably the hardest part of admissions). As I remember, Sowell's general point was that the very top schools like Harvard (and I assume MIT) take a disproportionate fraction of the top minority students, and therefore to maintain "diversity" the lower tier schools will accept a fair fraction of minority students who aren't as qualified for the school (including ones who don't have much of a chance of making it). This cascades on down the quality/intensity ladder of schools, and is grossly unfair to a lot of the students who would be happy at a lower tier school but who struggle at best in the one they (initially) attend. Admittance to graduation rates are instructive.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]