3 ms·
So a source with no reference value whatsoever no longer appears DIRECTLY as a Google result for certain kinds of searches that might be expected to turn up rel
by tokenadult 17y ago
So a source with no reference value whatsoever no longer appears DIRECTLY as a Google result for certain kinds of searches that might be expected to turn up reliable information. I thought that was a big part of what Page Rank was all about in the first place. Would that the same thing would happen to the many crank pages that turn up in searches on medical topics.
- karzeem 17y agoIt's not really a question of how relevant ED is. The issue is that a government had Google censor something which is well within the bounds of free (albeit offensive) speech.
- tokenadult 17y agoGovernments (courts) also enforce judgments for defamation, but we don't call that censorship either. One way I like to exercise my free speech is to be careful in my use of legal language, and to remind readers here that not every action that keeps something from being Web-indexed or posted, even if it is an action taken by a government, is properly called "censorship." What happened here appears to be Google responding to a citizen complaint under an Australian law that I might indeed disagree with, but which does not constitute a prior restrain on what is published on the Web, and indeed has not stopped the website in question from continuing to be posted. After edit: Google also removes on its own initiative spam links from its search results. No one seems to complain about this except the spammers. I think that is great customer service, except that Google recently needs to do more of that. That too is not censorship. It is simply Google deciding what its business model is for delivering search results. You have the right to operate a website. Google also has the right to operate a website. Google decides whether or not to comply with applicable local law if there is some legal issue raised by its serving up search results in a particular place. If Google really doesn't like local law, it can use its bully pulpit to advocate a different law, or hire lawyers or lobbyists to change the law.
- zck 17y agoGoogle isn't a pure reference site. It exists to show users things they're searching for. If people want to find the Encyclopedia Dramatica article for Aborigines when searching for "Aborigines and encyclopedia", Google should show it.
- tokenadult 17y agoEncyclopedia Dramatica is still the top result for a search on "Encyclopedia Dramatica." http://www.google.com/search?q=Encyclopedia+Dramatica http://www.google.com/search?q=Encyclopedia+Dramatica Currently, lots of good stuff shows up on a search for "Aborigines and encyclopedia," http://www.google.com/search?q=Aborigines+and+encyclopedia http://www.google.com/search?q=Aborigines+and+encyclopedia so no harm, no foul.
- zck 17y agoSo because, in your opinion, there are other results that have "good stuff", that means that government censorship is ok?
- tokenadult 17y agoYou ask a fair question. In general, I don't support government censorship, and especially not prior restraint of mass media (such as exists in China today). But I also have trouble characterizing what happened in the case discussed in this thread as "government censorship," inasmuch as the site is still posted for all the world to view (and for much of the world to become more interested in, as a result of this controversy). As another reply in this thread points out, Google's response seems to be standard operating procedure for Google much like what Google does in many other countries around the world. I am not an Australian resident, much less an Australian citizen, so I will defer to the constituents of the constitutional commonwealth that is Australia to decide whether the current policy in Australia is a good idea or not. But I don't think Google is deserving of particular criticism here, and I think the blog that publicized this story might have devoted more time to how Google is spammed up by quacks on medical issues or constrained by dictatorial governments like the government of China.