5 ms·
"Entanglement lets the measurement of one particle instantaneously determine the state of a partner particle, no matter how far away it may be" No. No! No!!!
by lisper 11y ago
"Entanglement lets the measurement of one particle instantaneously determine the state of a partner particle, no matter how far away it may be"
No. No! No!!! This meme has really got to die. A measurement of one entangled particle does NOTHING to the other particle. Its state is exactly the same as it was before. In fact, the whole concept of "before" and "after" a remote measurement doesn't even make sense because it depends on your frame of reference!
- zby 11y ago'determine' does not mean 'change' - does it?
- lisper 11y agoThe issue is not so much with the word "determine" as it is with the word "instantaneously". You could say "Entanglement lets the measurement of one particle instantaneously frob the state of a partner particle" without knowing or specifying what the word "frob" means and you'd have the same problem: you're claiming that measuring one particle does something to the other particle, and does it instantaneously and, moreover, that this is mysterious because the two particles are far apart (hence the slogan "spooky action at a distance"). All this is wrong. There is no "spooky action at a distance" because there is no action. Whether that action is "determining" or "frobbing" the state of the other particle is irrelevant. The correct story is that measurement and entanglement are the same physical phenomenon. The creation of an EPR pair is the first step in any measurement process. The correlations in EPR measurements derive from exactly the same physical process as the correlations in "ordinary" measurements (I put "ordinary" in scare quotes because, as I said, even "ordinary" measurements start with the creation of an EPR pair). When you "measure" the two halves of an EPR pair what you are really doing is performing two measurements on whatever system produced the EPR pair to begin with. When you look at it that way it is not at all surprising that the measurements should be correlated. For more details see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEaecUuEqfc http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf http://www.flownet.com/ron/QM.pdf
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoSorrt, but you're flat-out wrong, and the sources you link aren't credible. (That's not even a journal paper.) I suggest you read Scott Aaronson's explanation of why you're wrong (he understands this better than me): http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?cat=33 http://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?cat=33
- lisper 11y agoHere's the credible citation: http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605002 http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605002 (It's ironic, BTW, that you should complain that my citation is "not even a journal paper" when yours isn't either.) And BTW2, Aaronson's blog post doesn't contradict my position. The Bell inequality violations are indeed real. They just aren't caused by "spooky action at a distance." They are caused by the classical correlations that arise when you trace over the quantum wave function of the universe in order to isolate a subsystem. And BTW3, I actually did submit that paper to Physics Today back in the day. It was rejected, not because it was wrong, but because it wasn't anything new. (It's amazing how the Physics world bifurcates into two camps: those who think that the connection between entanglement and measurement is common knowledge, and those who adamantly deny that it is true.)
- hellofunk 11y ago>It's amazing how the Physics world bifurcates into two camps: those who think that the connection between entanglement and measurement is common knowledge, and those who adamantly deny that it is true. The fact that there are two legitimate camps means that no one knows for sure what is happening. And you are obviously in one of those camps. So to insist the world is a particular way is to deny how much is still unknown and acknowledged by others in the physics community.
- lisper 11y agoThe difference is that one camp has the math solidly on its side, and the other camp has to invoke the extra-physical hypothesis that measurement is somehow different (non-unitary, non-reversible) from everything else.
- richmarr 11y ago> 'determine' does not mean 'change' - does it? Yeah, it does, amongst other things. Unfortunately in that context two of its meanings (to discover & to decide) could have been appicable.
- Confusion 11y agoYou are asserting something as true that is actually under dispute. Whether the state of the particle was already determined is the million dollar question. Importantly, under non-local theories, it doesn't have to be. Superpositions can be real and not just mathematical entities.
- lisper 11y agoIt's only disputed by people who haven't actually looked at the math. And I didn't say the state of the particle was already determined. It wasn't. Yes, of course superpositions are real. Yes, of course the Bell inequalities are violated. Yes, this eliminates all local hidden variables theories. Yes, it seems like this necessarily leads to the conclusion that there is spooky action at a distance. But that's wrong. To see why, read the paper or watch the video.
- armitron 11y agoYou do realize this is an open question right? No jokeprod paper or video is going to put it to rest. You sound like a religious nutcase.
- lisper 11y agoI realize that a lot of people think it's an open question. These people are wrong. And the difference between me and a religious nutcase is that I can back up my position with math.
- gsteinb88 11y agoImportant to remember, especially if you're practicing physics or engineering in any form: models are not the real world. You're (kind of) right about the (typical interpretation of) the models we use for entanglement, but open questions in this field include things like whether a wavefunction is "real" or just a mathematical tool that seems to get the right results at the length/energy scales we look at. tl;dr: Just because you have an equation doesn't mean that equation corresponds to anything real. This is the same mistake people make all the time with statistics -- the math is easy, finding the right math to use can be very hard.