2 ms·
The Wikipedia article has no criticism section. It might be great as taxonomy of problem solutions, but there is no reliable evidence that it works as a method
by varjag 11y ago
The Wikipedia article has no criticism section.
It might be great as taxonomy of problem solutions, but there is no reliable evidence that it works as a methodology. Reducing research activity to a bunch of codified chess-like moves is a huge temptation. However I haven't seen its adepts producing any unexpected results (in practice, not on some TRIZ textbook puzzle). The solutions were on par with what you'd expect from a person of comparable intelligence, experience and education background otherwise.
- graeham 11y agoI learned it as part of my 2nd year mechanical engineering design course. It was a great way to teach concept generation to novices and expand awareness of alternative solutions. As our experiance grows, we become more aware of the possibilities. I don't think any of our class still uses TRIZ in their professional work, but learning the process of seeking inventive solutions from other applications is critical. A parallel is perhaps biomimetics [1], an active current research area of 'design inspired by life/ biology'. Often, it is controversial if the invention was truely inspired by nature, or just made for good marketing. 'Shark skin' swimsuits were named by marketers after the actual invention [2]. Our experiance with heavier-than-air flight was terrible until we stopped trying to mimic how birds fly. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomimetics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biomimetics [2] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/swimsuit-is-not-like-shark-skin-6699673.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/swimsuit-is-not-li...
- varjag 11y agoHad bionics (the older name of biomemetics) on tip of the tongue for analogy sake too, but felt am not familiar enough with it. I however worked and shared hobbies with a few people who were into TRIZ: our alma mater was one of the hubs. Never seen it make a difference, but maybe it has its merits as pedagogic tool.