3 ms·
When you order a ride with Lyft, a contract is established between you and Lyft. You pay Lyft $10. Payment to the driver is a cost incurred by Lyft in providi
by rahimnathwani 11y ago
When you order a ride with Lyft, a contract is established between you and Lyft. You pay Lyft $10. Payment to the driver is a cost incurred by Lyft in providing services to you.
When you order something on eBay, a contract is established between you and the seller. You pay the seller $10. The seller gives eBay a cut. eBay's cut is a cost incurred by the seller in providing goods to you.
- jcdavis 11y agoWe can argue this one all day :). I would argue Lyft is merely providing the service of matching me with the driver (who is a 3rd party, specifically not an employee), for which it takes a fixed cut. The driver is the primary provider of the service, and as such Lyft is merely an agent, and should follow net revenue reporting. Really Lyft (and Uber) fall on both sides of EITF 99-19, but I suspect when Uber IPOs you wont find "gross revenue" anywhere in their S-1
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"We can argue this one all day :)." Actually, we don't need to :) It's clear as day in Lyft's T&Cs. You are correct. Lyft is an agent, not a principal to the transaction.
- jcdavis 11y agoIt makes sense - As soon as they claim they are a principal the lawsuits from their drivers about employement status become more legitimate.
- antr 11y agoIt's incorrect to do that, and no leading accounting firm would sign-off those statements. The service provided by Lyft is not the taxi ride, but the arrangement of the taxi ride. Lyft is acting as an agent, not the principle, and consequently they can only recognise the booking fee, not the entire service.
- rahimnathwani 11y ago"The service provided by Lyft is not the taxi ride, but the arrangement of the taxi ride." You are right. I was wrong about how Lyft's customer agreement works. I looked up the Lyft T&Cs[0] and they specifically say: "In exchange for permitting you to offer your Services through the Lyft Platform and marketplace as a Driver, you agree to pay Lyft (and permit Lyft to retain) a fee of up to 20% (the “Administrative Fee”) of the Ride Fees paid by Riders for such Services." This makes it clear that Lyft is acting as an agent (like eBay) not as a principal (like Tarsnap). [0] https://www.lyft.com/terms https://www.lyft.com/terms
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 11y agoNonsense. Lyft's drivers could be contractors. Tarsnap's revenue is all the picodollars users spend, even though I pass quadrillions of them over to Amazon to pay for the storage I'm reselling. But Amazon is definitely not my employee.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 11y agoI'm not trying to answer the "contractor vs. employee" question. There are many factors which go into that determination and I don't know enough about Lyft to offer an informed opinion about that. My point is just that a contract between you and Lyft which states that Lyft will get someone to drive you somewhere does not imply that Lyft's drivers are employees, because the presence of a contract between Lyft and its customers is entirely consistent with Lyft's drivers being contractors.