5 ms·
Yeah, but if they want to "sell" me a widget, I should be able to behave in the assumption that I then own it and can do whatever I like with it. If I buy an I
by bigiain 11y ago
Yeah, but if they want to "sell" me a widget, I should be able to behave in the assumption that I then own it and can do whatever I like with it.
If I buy an IKEA table, and choose to take it apart and assemble it differently, I'm not going to expect the police to come knocking at my door saying "IKEA says you can't do that."
If they want to retain ownership and control over "their" widget, that's fine - I'm happy enough to pay Apple something less than half of what I used to pay for a physical CD - but if you put a "thing" on a shelf in a store, and I can pick it up and hand over some cash and walk out with it, there's no assumption that the manufacturer has any more legal right to tell me what I can and can't do with it when I get it home (there may be _other_ interested parties, if I turned a TIG welder into a homebuilt Taser, the police might come after me themselves, but not on behalf of the manufacturer.)
I'm not saying they can't fo it. But I am saying they shouldn't be allowed to call that "selling a TIG welder". Because it's not what people usually think it means.
- nsajko 11y agoThe public should be educated about this. Maybe printing and distributing some flyers would be beneficial. (Does the EFF maybe already do something like this?)
- pjc50 11y agoIKEA says you can't do that If you run a website telling people how to modify their IKEA furniture, you may have it confiscated by the trademark "police": http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/06/ikea-waits-8-years-then-shuts-down-ikeahackers-site-with-trademark-claim/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/06/ikea-waits-8-year... http://www.ikeahackers.net/2014/06/big-changes-coming-to-ikeahackers.html http://www.ikeahackers.net/2014/06/big-changes-coming-to-ike...
- Vendan 11y agolol, hilarious how the site is still up and using the exact same name and everything. Doesn't seem like they actually "confiscated it". Also, using a trademark however you want and using a physical object that you own however you want are radically different concepts.
- Asbostos 11y agoIf you buy a computer, this has never been true. You only get a license to use the software that comes with it and not complete freedom to do what you want. For example, you can't copy Windows off your computer on to your friend's. You're even restricted in making backup copies for yourself. We've been happy to accept that restriction since the invention of copyright. A guy in his basement with no connection to the outside world has always been able to break the law by pressing the wrong sequence of keys on his computer. DRM circumvention law is just an extension of those restrictions, not a quantitatively new thing. So I think we already call this "selling a computer" or "selling a CD" or "selling a phone" and should get used to what "selling a welder" seems to mean now too. I do kind of wonder what does and doesn't count as circumventing though. Can you pull out the transformer and connect your own homemade controller to it? What if you reuse the same power electronics too? What if you also reuse the same computer but put your own software on it? Can you even unplug the handle and plug it into another welder that has different capabilities?
- kefka 11y agoFor the last 5 years, I've been running on almost exclusively Free Software. Cases where that hasn't been the case are in ATI and nVidia drivers. I can easily plop in an Intel graphics card and even route around that, if I chose.
- Asbostos 11y agoEven UEFI? Even no Windows when you first bought the computer?
- pdkl95 11y ago> You only get a license to use the software Nonsense. Show me the contract I signed that created that situation. (difficulty: a post-purchase EULA or inside-the-shrinkwrap document is not a contract) I can't copy Windows because of copyright law. If I buy a book I own that copy. I cannot copy it, but I can do what I want with that copy, because the author's rights end at the first sale[1]. Now this does get complicated when you bring in the DMCA's anti-circumvention clause. This is a separate problem that restricts the use of purchased goods. There is a recent attempt to use the copyright on the firmware in in a product as leverage to extend these anti-circumvention restrictions to the entire product (see: John Deere[2]). As this drama is ongoing, we will have to wait to see how it is handled, but I would bet that the first sale doctrine is upheld; not because I think that outcome is likely, but because the alternative is de facto the end of personal property rights, which will not be a stable society. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine [2] http://ifixit.org/blog/7192/john-deere-mess/ http://ifixit.org/blog/7192/john-deere-mess/