4 ms·
NVIDIA Titan X today: 336 GB/s, 7 teraflops Intel Xeon Phi next year: 400 GB/s, 6 teraflops NVIDIA Pascal next year: 1 TB/s, >10? teraflops NVIDIA still wins
by modeless 11y ago
NVIDIA Titan X today: 336 GB/s, 7 teraflops
Intel Xeon Phi next year: 400 GB/s, 6 teraflops
NVIDIA Pascal next year: 1 TB/s, >10? teraflops
NVIDIA still wins for my applications. Intel is aiming too low.
- wyldfire 11y agoYeah, Intel's behind the curve for sure. But what if they had a soup-to-nuts open ecosystem? IMO that can be a real winner for simple, convenient deployment of a total solution. It doesn't make up for being a generation+ behind, but I expect they'll catch up over time.
- modeless 11y agoI'm not sure Intel will catch up. Underestimating the power and importance of graphics hardware seems to be a chronic problem that they have. It's a shame NVIDIA's Project Denver custom CPU didn't seem to work out very well. I was really hoping they'd be able to produce a CPU worthy of pairing with their top-end GPUs, to make an x86-free workstation and lessen their dependence on Intel. Wouldn't that be something?
- rdtsc 11y agoWhy do you think they still do it? It would seem they have enough people for someone to check NVIDIA's numbers. Are they offering something closer to general purpose CPUs, something that could schedule OS threads to run on it?
- ScottBurson 11y agoAccording to the article hendzen linked to, the Phi processors are absolutely general purpose CPUs -- they can be the main CPU on the board and can boot and run stock OSes. This is much more powerful than a GPU, which is fundamentally SIMD -- it can hit TFLOPS speeds running hundreds of threads doing different things. While not everyone will need this power, I suspect it will open up entire new classes of applications.
- makomk 11y agoIt still only hits teraflops speed when you're running very wide SIMD code - non-SIMD stuff is a lot slower, probably roughly the same speed penalty as running non-SIMD code on a GPU based on what they've released. Not only that, most researcher's very wide SIMD code is written for CUDA which this doesn't support. Oh, and the AVX-512 instructions required to take advantage of the full speed of this aren't used by any Intel product currently in existence - you basically have to develop code specifically for this board.
- pandaman 11y agoIntel gives narrower and faster threads. For some applications it's better than wide slow threads of mainstream GPUs. E.g. Intel's favorite demo of raytracing is a terrible task for a GPU. I don't know if anybody is actually doing raytracing outside demos or if there are practical tasks that call for such an architecture.
- gh02t 11y agoMonte Carlo particle transport is a big application. It's very similar to ray tracing (ray tracing for rendering is really a special case of particle transport, specific to photons with simplified physics), except that the interactions are a lot more complicated. This is a very important task in a lot of HPC fields like astrophysics, nuclear physics etc and it isn't as well suited to CUDA style parallelism because the obvious minimum unit of computation (a single particle) has a lot of branching and data lookups. Phi is probably a bit better suited, though it still has issues with all the data lookups, which aren't very amenable to caching strategies that might otherwise help.
- pandaman 11y agoThanks, I did not know about this. Yes, I figure memory access is still an issue for them since each core runs only 4 threads.
- greglindahl 11y agoSupercomputers are not just compute. They also need networking. Knights Landing has a 100 gbit specialized network on-die, called Omni-Path. The competition has to use a discrete chip for that, and Intel's got a more scalable network fabric, apparently.
- zvrba 11y agoIntel Xeon Phi: general-purpose CPU w/o ridiculous stuff like warps, groups, different memory types, etc.
- berkut 11y agoThis can run native x86 code though (although to take advantage of the architecture code might have to be re-written to some extent). So this means you can run the same code on a desktop Xeon as this one.
- IanCal 11y ago> NVIDIA still wins for my applications Just a wild guess, but perhaps different people have different applications where GPUs don't fit in as well.
- sklogic 11y agoGood luck getting to that tflop upper limit on anything but the most trivially parallel tasks. Phi got much more flexibility than the GPUs.
- mrb 11y agoActually Titan X is 6.1 teraflops (single-precision) and 0.192 teraflops (double-precision). But this Xeon Phi is 8+ teraflops (single-precision) and 3 teraflops (double-precision). So Knights Landing is a bit faster for SP, and ~15x faster for DP(!)
- mtanski 11y agoAppealing to numbers without more context doesn't make for a very interesting conversation. I'm going to guess that your applications do some kind of streaming numerical processing or maybe some kind of large linear algebra. And, GPU cores are great that. There's other applications that have a more complex work profile in terms of interleaving branchy logic with numerical processing. A good example of this might be a OLAP Database. They need do some query parsing, building a plan, optimizing that plan, work with indexes, do data decompression (traditional schemes and data specific schemes) then process that data, and do operations on it (join, filter, aggregate). There's so many steps in that process and some of them require branching logic some of then numerical processing and some of them a combination of both. If you breakup a large query (partition) the Phi being good at both kind of computation and having fast RAM makes it an ideal platform to develop this.