3 ms·
Niall Ferguson’s argument style is tendentious and question-begging, painfully oversimplified and predictable in the extreme, which he tries to paper over with
by jacobolus 11y ago
Niall Ferguson’s argument style is tendentious and question-begging, painfully oversimplified and predictable in the extreme, which he tries to paper over with rhetorical flourish. It seems like every other sentence he says something jaw-droppingly wrongheaded. Nothing of his I’ve ever read has contained even a shred of insight, and he’s infuriating and frankly exhausting to read. His “success” owes to his ability to effectively flatter a particular group of rich men, but I don’t know anyone of substance who takes him seriously.
Just ignore him and move on.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ysilver 11y agoI have tried to take his work seriously. At first glance it looks like it should be thorough and center-right -- not a bad way to read history when read along-side differing accounts. However, he can't help himself from reducing his voluminous work to strangely simple political jabs. Maybe if he stuck to long-form topics from long-ago periods he could keep his credibility.