3 ms·
In quite possibly my only point of agreement with Noam Chomsky, I think our discussions of AI are impoverished because they turn on a distinction of language no
by patio11 17y ago
In quite possibly my only point of agreement with Noam Chomsky, I think our discussions of AI are impoverished because they turn on a distinction of language not of fact. Machines that can "think" are AI, machines that can do impressive calculations but not "think" are just impressive calculators. This is not a statement about AI, this is a statement about the English word "think". It sheds about as much light as asking whether an aircraft carrier can swim. (I am informed that aircraft carriers do indeed swim... in Russian.)
A lot of the other "Oh, that's just a cheap trick" non-AI things are a) much more useful to humans than the sci-fi notions people think of when they think AI and b) actually exist in the status quo. For example, if I told you that there exists a program which can make evidence-based judgments of a human's character to tell you whether they are likely to be trustworthy or not in their future business dealings, you would probably say "Egads! That is clearly AI! Holy cow, that is lightyears ahead of passing the Turing Test, and we're nowhere near passing the Turing Test!"
But if I told you "The program is called a FICO score" then, pfft, that isn't AI, that's just clever math and good selection of data sources.
This is one of the reasons why academic AI is, ahem, pretty dead as a field: after you actually get something working we drum you out of the field. Telling the topic of a document by reading it and understanding what it is about? AI! Leveraging anchor text on the link graph to do the work for you? Boooooooring. Granted, billion dollar business boring but still boooooooooring.
- ajross 17y agoIndeed. And from the other end work in neurology and applied computer science continues to push out the boundaries of things that count as mere "cheap tricks". 40 years ago, no one would have looked at the face recognition and red-eye reduction features on our $100 cameras and said it was "obvious". It looks a lot like "thinking" if you don't understand it. Likewise the operation of much of the brain is better understood than it was in the 60's, and we're less likely to ascribe magic terms like "thinking" to the brain; even things like consciousness are starting to look like a trick (albeit not a cheap one).
- camccann 17y agoIt sheds about as much light as asking whether an aircraft carrier can swim. (I am informed that aircraft carriers do indeed swim... in Russian.) "The question of whether machines can think... is about as relevant as the question of whether submarines can swim." -- Edsger W. Dijkstra This is one of the reasons why academic AI is, ahem, pretty dead as a field: after you actually get something working we drum you out of the field. Even if you're really just using techniques originally developed by AI researchers. It's kind of silly.
- a-priori 17y agoEven if you're really just using techniques originally developed by AI researchers. It's kind of silly. ... in retrospect.