4 ms·
The appeal isn't about entrapment, it's about wholesale warrantless surveillance of American citizens. > Mohamud is the very first criminal defendant to challe
by DennisP 11y ago
The appeal isn't about entrapment, it's about wholesale warrantless surveillance of American citizens.
> Mohamud is the very first criminal defendant to challenge the FAA before a court of appeals, which opens the door for a hearing before the U.S. Supreme Court. The appeal has widespread implications: The controversial law provides the legal framework for the mass surveillance programs that Edward Snowden revealed in 2013.
> “It’s not an exaggeration,” Patrick Toomey, an American Civil Liberties Union attorney, told BuzzFeed News, “to say that the privacy rights of millions of Americans potentially hang in the balance of his case.”
- rtl49 11y agoI didn't claim it was about entrapment. I was anticipating a potential objection, that Mohamud was 'radicalized' by the agents involved in this situation, which another comment implied. I understand the legal implications. If only our legal system were not organized such that one must invest so much effort into proving 'standing,' perhaps we could respond to the situation rationally instead of choosing between two potentially negative outcomes.
- aidenn0 11y agoI think it is a good balance. Cops do not want to let bad guys off the hook, so knowing that if they improperly collect evidence it will do so aligns the incentives well.
- tremon 11y agoCops are as susceptible to rationalization as anyone else. If they improperly collect evidence but are not punished directly for it, they will not view it as their error: they will view it as "the system" has failed to follow through on their hard work. This might then lead to more cops taking matters in their own hands rather than handing the suspect over to the prosecution.
- eru 11y ago> The appeal isn't about entrapment, it's about wholesale warrantless surveillance of American citizens. Why should they have it any better than the unAmerican citizens of the world?
- rtl49 11y agoI don't believe he or she claimed they should, only that this was the basis of the appeal.
- jedmeyers 11y agoThe Constitution of the United States only protects US persons (not citizens) from unreasonable surveillance. Spying on "unAmerican citizens of the world" is the direct duty of many of the US spy agencies, of which there are 17.