4 ms·
Particularly disturbing is the implication that the portable card readers distributed by the banks (we have four here in my house alone) can be used by muggers
by barrkel 17y ago
Particularly disturbing is the implication that the portable card readers distributed by the banks (we have four here in my house alone) can be used by muggers etc. to verify PINs being stolen at knifepoint (or gunpoint, as the case may be), and already may have been involved in past murder and torture cases.
- jacquesm 17y agoIt was a fairly obvious thing too, when they were suggesting finger print authentication one of the first snags to come up was 'how do you detect if the finger is still attached to the human it was born on'. The bank teller had a function other than just being a cost on an itemized list, they were people and people are good at spotting unusual patterns. Once we switched to ATMs and now to online banking the pin taking the place of your digital signature the push is on to make you the responsible party for your bank balance, even though the banks could (and should) take more responsibility and actions to safeguard your balance. Even velocity controls are not adequate, as the torture case clearly shows. But then again, in times before all that came to pass it was possible to take your family members hostage while you visit the bank too. It's just that now we don't need you to go to the bank (and potentially alert the police) but all we need is four digits. After that you are literally disposable.
- barrkel 17y agoThe annoying thing is that a very simple mitigation against this attack is possible - don't indicate an error upon entry of a bad PIN. Even better is a duress PIN.
- jacquesm 17y agoYep. Convenience is another reason for this probably, I guess the banks did not want to deal with people that have managed to 'lock' their pin card but aren't aware of it.
- patio11 17y agoalready may have been involved in past murder and torture cases. This is the very definition of a movie plot threat: it makes for gripping drama, but is less effective and far more risky than just doing the traditional thing and saying "I'm Bank of America. What is your PIN number?" to as many people as possible. I would be astonished if "tortured for your two-factor identification" was even visible next to old stand-bys like "killed for cash/jewelry/sneakers."