3 ms·
There is an important piece of historical trivia involving Galton and regression. Galton documented regression to the mean. But why did it happen? In an era
by btilly 11y ago
There is an important piece of historical trivia involving Galton and regression. Galton documented regression to the mean. But why did it happen? In an era before genetics was understood the most natural explanation was that each species and race had "a natural type" that it was regressing to. This contradicted Darwin's theory of evolution, and lead to widespread doubts about Darwin's theory until Fischer managed to demonstrate why statistics + Mendelian genetics predicted regression to the mean, and provided a possible mechanism for Darwin's theory of evolution.
It is natural to view history as a steady march of progress to our current scientific consensus. But history doesn't actually look like that. And this is an interesting example where it doesn't.
- vanderZwan 11y agoWas that sudden switch from Galton to Fisher conscious or a mistake?
- btilly 11y agoConscious. Sorry for not being clearer. Galton documented the phenomena of regression to the mean in inheritance of height in the 1870s. (The children of two tall parents tended to be tall, but shorter than the parents. The children of two short parents tended to be short, but taller than the parents.) Similar phenomena were documented in a wide variety of species, as well as more complex variations. All of this lead to a belief that there was such a thing as a "natural type" which a species or race returned to, which cast doubt on Darwin's theories for several decades. After Mendelian genetics was rediscovered in the early 1900s, Fisher explained the phenomena from population genetics. Once the results of the breeding experiments were explained by genetics and statistics, we could reconcile field observations about inheritance with Darwin's theory.
- vanderZwan 11y agoThank you for the follow-up; I figured it was either a mistake and very simple, or not a mistake and with crucial information missing. The extra information cleared that up :)