3 ms·
I'm actually thinking something completely opposite; do we really need to have users input their own password? Why not just generate one for them? Users are not
by zokier 11y ago
I'm actually thinking something completely opposite; do we really need to have users input their own password? Why not just generate one for them? Users are notoriously bad at creating passwords (on average), and generating one for them would allow us to throw away all that complex password rule dancing.
For the people that are already using password managers it would be fairly minor change in workflow when creating accounts (which is relatively rare occasion anyways), and for the rest it would be massive improvement in security.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIn my naive thinking, I'd let my computer and the server manage passwords independent of me. Let them share some secret; then my machine creates a 1024-bit challenge and get a response from the server. Why involve me at all? I'm terrible at managing large random things.
- bradleyjg 11y agoIf you always used one computer that would be fine. But if you create your account on your home computer and then want to use it on your work computer, your ipad, your android phone, and occasionally at your brother's house then we need some way of authenticating you instead of your computer. And even if you don't want to log on from any of those places, eventually you are going to get a new computer.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoAnd how does that differ from a huge, unrememberable password?
- zokier 11y agoThat sounds a lot like TLS client side certificates. Sure, something like would be nice but getting there would practically require new standards, then those standards need to percolate to server and client software across different platforms, then users will need to get used to them etc etc. Meanwhile autogenerated passwords can be made with a perl cgi script, be compatible with Mosaic from 1995, and be immediately familiar with most users.
- finnn 11y agoWhat new standards would be required? All modern browsers that I'm aware of support TLS client certificates, there's even an HTML5 <keygen> element that causes the browser to generate a CSR and send it to the server for signing.
- timfrietas 11y agoMost users do not use password managers, thus most users won't remember the password you generate and you will have the same problem.
- angelbob 11y agoThat tends to degenerate into resetting the password every time, or logging in from the password reset email you sent them. In either case, you've moved security to the user's email program which is (sadly) probably an improvement.