3 ms·
> US Astronauts were very aware of the early Soviet deaths and failures and wanted nothing of them. So they jumped in an overengineered spacecraft, built by bu
by rdtsc 11y ago
> US Astronauts were very aware of the early Soviet deaths and failures and wanted nothing of them.
So they jumped in an overengineered spacecraft, built by bureaucrats from NASA, sometimes 8 at a time, and as a result more astronauts died.
The shuttle went the way of the dodo and we are using Soviet's 70s technology to get into orbit. If anything, the history is hard to ignore. And the irony is there too, staring us it the face.
Also nevermind that Soviet's Buran prototype was the first fully automated space shuttle, so again autocratic state wins? (going by your labels here...)
> Environments built on fear perform sub-optimally.
History proves you wrong again. A lot of environments built on fear produced rugged dependable products.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> History proves you wrong again. A lot of environment built on fear produced rugged dependable products. I think he meant political fear - in modern terms, the fear of your manager yelling at you, or firing you, or demoting you - and back then, of your manager sending you off to break rocks in the far east. That's not the same thing as a fear of your hardware killing a man, and over-engineering as a result.
- rdtsc 11y agoIn a way that is not different than NASA. Perhaps at a local level, large bureaucracies are not that different. Even if political environment at the very top is so different. (One can argue perhaps that large companies with hundreds of thousands of employees are like mini-communist, central-planned economy countries with all the pain and inefficiencies built in).
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> In a way that is not different than NASA. I'm not aware of anyone at NASA walking into what they knew was a death sentence, or was ever sent to a hard labor camp in a harsh climate.
- PerfectDlite 11y ago> In a way that is not different than NASA. Do you know about sharashka? Soviet space mastermind Korolev was transferred from Siberian camp to a separate camp built for scientists so they can work their hearts out in hope that they will not be punished. Do we had something similar in NASA?
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>The shuttle went the way of the dodo and we are using Soviet's 70s technology to get into orbit. We're between systems, like the seven years between Apollo and the STS. Its a happy coincidence Russia still has a legacy system for lifting people into the largely STS built and ferried ISS. The SLS/Orion and SpaceX systems will be the next generation of spaceflight that will take us out of the LEO. Neither the Soyuz or the STS could leave LEO. >was the first fully automated space shuttle, so again autocratic state wins? The Buran sent as many men into space as Zimbabwe. Zero. That's not a "win" in anyone's book. It was a prototype and a blatant copy of the STS. The STS had automatic capabilities but astronauts, feared rightly, that if the landing gear went down accidentally they would die. The Shuttle does NOT HAVE the capabilities to lift its own landing gear. That's done by a ground crew. If this went off accidentally in space then these people are stranded. If it goes off during re-entry they would die. Having a removable and stowed cable for plugging the flight computer into the landing gear was a rational compromise. This allowed scenarios where an abandoned shuttle could fly itself home.
- rdtsc 11y ago> That's not a "win" in anyone's book. It was a great win for two reasons -- they could do it technically and they proved it, even automated the whole thing (just like Zimbabwe right ;-) ). And the other win was they realized this was an expensive endeavor and not a very good approach to taking people into space. It took Americans many hundreds of billions dollars and lives to realize that? > We're between systems, like the seven years between Apollo and the STS. That makes sense, hadn't thought of it that way. It has been only 4-5 years since last launch. Yeah I am looking forward to Orion/SLS! > Its a happy coincidence Russia still has a legacy system for lifting people into the largely STS built and ferried ISS. Is it? From a country that did pretty well with many firsts in space, builds reliable military hardware, killed less astronauts/cosmonauts than our Shuttle. I mean, yeah, we all hate Russia and their commie regime, but I think it is a disservice a bit to downplay their engineers.
- PerfectDlite 11y ago> we are using Soviet's 70s technology to get into orbit. If you're digging that far in the past, we're using German's 40s technology.