4 ms·
Funny how politicians twist reason to suit their own ends. Bad guys use guns, but apparently were not allowed to ban them because they'll somehow find a way to
by smcl 11y ago
Funny how politicians twist reason to suit their own ends. Bad guys use guns, but apparently were not allowed to ban them because they'll somehow find a way to get them no matter what. So the solution is to legalise them.
However when it comes to encryption, bad guys use it so it needs to be banned!
It's like they have it completely backwards.
- PKop 11y agoWho are "they"? Many politicians are on the same side of each debate, wanting to restrict the rights of free people in the name of safety and security. I'm curious, do you see a distinction between the two issues? Sounds like you're on opposite sides for each of them.
- grhino 11y agoI think the argument is that if bad guys didn't have guns, then there would be no reason for good guys to have guns except to fend off wildlife. However, even if the bad guys didn't have encryption, we would still want good guys to have encryption to prevent the bad guys from intercepting private and sensitive communications.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>then there would be no reason for good guys to have guns except to fend off wildlife. Ignoring the issues such as fending off bad guys (so what if they only have a knife, I'd rather bring a gun to a knife fight), hunting wild life, shooting for fun, owning collections, any many other reasons. Outright dismissing all of those is like just dismissing the need to protect private electronic communications.
- CamperBob2 11y agoSome would argue that banning tools of any kind is a stupid and feckless way to address cultural problems.
- chki 11y agoBut that arguing would clearly be flawed. I could thing of a lot of weapons that I would not want to see in the hands of everybody I meet on the street. I think it is partially correct to say that about certain information based "tools" (like encryption or information in newspapers) but sometimes that is not true as well, for example with certain malware
- CamperBob2 11y agoHistorically, though, the real threat is usually a state actor -- often one's own government -- that has been granted (or has seized) a monopoly on such tools. In particular, the modern notion that the state is the only rightful wielder of force has an unlimited downside. Terrorism is pretty far down the list of things that frighten me.
- pcunite 11y agoExcellent point and what many people miss. Look at history.
- chki 11y agoThe problem with having everybody possess potentially deathly tools is not terrorism, but crime in general. I, for myself, can think of a lot more crimes committed by normal people than the government. The historical argument is of course not completely unreasonable, but there are also an awful lot of discrepancies when looking at states government today and 300 years ago. At least in Europe, where I live, the government can be trusted in a lot of issues --- especially it is highly likely that they _try_ to do what is best and are no "evil emperors".
- CamperBob2 11y agoAt least in Europe, where I live, the government can be trusted in a lot of issues --- especially it is highly likely that they _try_ to do what is best and are no "evil emperors". The Europeans are fond of reminding Americans that we think 200 years is a long time. So, how long ago was the Stasi disbanded, again?