5 ms·
> best long term prospects for its citizens Seems like you are conveniently ignoring the 300+ % of Japan's GDP of Public debt. Yeah, a bright future.
by ekianjo 11y ago
> best long term prospects for its citizens
Seems like you are conveniently ignoring the 300+ % of Japan's GDP of Public debt. Yeah, a bright future.
- vox_mollis 11y agoI believe the stock HN response to mathematically certain sovereign debt disaster is either "print your way out" or "grow your way out".
- ekianjo 11y ago> is either "print your way out" I have yet to see any country which was able to get to an actual way out by inflating their currency. Reality always catches up.
- antome 11y agoGermany made their way out after WWI, but lets just say the results weren't pretty. At least from historical precedent, it seems the best solution is to "cheat" your way out, by massively inflating a currency, then if hyperinflation kicks in, create a new currency in quick succession.
- Symmetry 11y agoHuh, there are plenty of examples. Italy did it more than once, for example. But it isn't obvious whether its better to inflate or to default - both are painful and you need to be running a surplus barring interest payments or they might be disastrous.
- JamesBarney 11y agoThe U.K went from a debt to gdp ratio of 225% to a low of 33%.[0] The U.S. went from a debt to gdp ratio of 120% down to 37%.[1] This isn't the first time countries have had to run large deficits. [0]http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/11697/debt/post-war-boom/ http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/11697/debt/post-war-boom/ [1]http://dailybail.com/home/chart-us-debt-to-gdp-1940-2015.html http://dailybail.com/home/chart-us-debt-to-gdp-1940-2015.htm...
- jazzyk 11y agoIn the US case, it "only" took 40+ years - and now we are sadly almost back at 100%+
- JamesBarney 11y agoWhich is not quite as long as it's been since the time we had a recession of this magnitude.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Retric 11y agoMost of that is internal debt, which is very different from over sea debt.
- veidr 11y agoWhy? (Not disputing, just would like to have a clear explanation.)
- Retric 11y agoLot's of reasons the most obvious is it does not impact trade or currency. However, from a repayment standpoint the debt payments are generally taxable which reduces the effective interest rate dramatically. Hypothetical example: Interest rates are 8%, inflation is 5% = 3% over inflation. Now tax that 8% at 30% and your paying 5.6% - 5% inflation = 0.6% effective rate. (Assuming you don't let interest compound tax free.)
- ddeck 11y agoIt most definitely affects the currency, and the currency of course affects trade. The core difference between internal and external debt - or more precisely debt denominated in a country's sovereign currency vs. foreign currency - is that a country can typically always avoid defaulting on domestic debt by printing more money, despite typical "independence" of central banks. Rates on domestic debt can also be controlled in a similar way. The Japanese Central Bank is currently undertaking a quantitative easing program of gargantuan proportions, which basically means that they create new money every month and use it to buy Japanese government bonds. They are, albeit indirectly, creating money and loaning it to the government, which then uses it to run a large deficit. Government social programs are significant. The effect on the currency has been dramatic, with the JPY depreciating nearly 40% over the last three years versus the dollar. The central is bank is expected by many analysts to expand the program in the near future. Although the stated intention is to generate inflation, a cynic might suggest that without such massive buying by the central bank, the governments enormous debt load would soon be at risk of becoming unsustainable - JGB interest rates could easily become unserviceable as investors become more concerned.
- jld89 11y agoAnd you are conveniently forgetting that Japan is the biggest creditor in the world and the one that possesses more foreign net assets than even China. So yes... definitely a bright future despite the colossal "debt".