3 ms·
You underestimate the degree to which people of violence listen to the language of violence. The article suggests the military conquest is the key of Daesh att
by varjag 11y ago
You underestimate the degree to which people of violence listen to the language of violence.
The article suggests the military conquest is the key of Daesh attractiveness. But similarly, its military loss will be its demise. Lost territory and decimated ranks will make it a lot less exciting to the recruits.
Harder wars have been fought and won before.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoI agree. The Taliban and Al Qaeda were routed in Afghanistan, and the only thing that saved them was a sympathetic government next door in Pakistan, allowing them to regroup and rearm. The Americans, had they stayed, could have protected the democratic government until it was strong enough to stand on its own, but war weariness and impatience caused them to withdraw prematurely. This was not a sign of jihadist strength and resilience, just good luck. Interviews with some of the fighters suggested actually that they were tired of war as well.
- maxharris 11y agoDaesh What do you think of this piece by Maajid Nawaz? Why Not Calling ISIS “Islamic” Hurts Muslim Reformers: http://jrbenjamin.com/2015/03/06/maajid-nawaz-why-not-calling-isis-islamic-hurts-muslim-reformers/ http://jrbenjamin.com/2015/03/06/maajid-nawaz-why-not-callin...
- varjag 11y agoI couldn't care less about Islamic. I'm not calling it "state".
- maxharris 11y agoUnfortunately it has courts, police, and a military. It has nearly 10 million citizens, and in articles about its territorial gains, it even appears on maps. It even collects taxes, repairs roads and runs electric utilities. The sad reality is that it is both quintessentially Islamic, and a state. If we refuse to acknowledge the reality of the situation today, we have no chance of destroying it in the future.
- varjag 11y agoIt's court, police and military are not independent structures but the same bunch of armed militants. If controlling a territory with sword and fire is the criterion of statehood, we have a bunch of states right now on our hands, including Taliban State, Boko Haram State and 18th Street State. I concur it's advantageous they are positioning themselves as a state though. It immediately translates their military defeats into social and political ones.