10 ms·
Cryptography exists independently from any corporation that may or may not use it in a messaging system.
by nitrogen 11y ago
Cryptography exists independently from any corporation that may or may not use it in a messaging system.
- mc32 11y agoUnless ISIS, etc. have better crypto minds than the likes of firms who spend billions in that domain (and still make mistakes), you're asking a lot from foot soldier terrorists by asking them to produce, to borrow from oracle, "unbreakable" bug free comms platform.
- nitrogen 11y agoBut it already exists. PGP and couriers. Taking encryption away from the innocent doesn't change that.
- mc32 11y agoThat slows down things. It also allows currier interception. If it's so easy, then, go ahead, replace all your daily encryption with gpg and couriers, see how effective you become.
- nitrogen 11y agoIt would also kill our modern economy. But it wouldn't prevent terrorism.
- mc32 11y agoHow would a hypothetical governments requiring mitm interception capability "kill the modern economy"? If China, The EU etc required it, others would follow... Ordinary people would keep on using gov't mandated mitm encrypted comms and apps. So long as there was protection from your neighbor snooping on you, and the gov't guarantees [whatever that means] it won't use it against you except in "combating terror" most people would go along with it. Just as with disease, you're not looking to eliminate it, you're looking to minimize it.
- nitrogen 11y agoYou're arguing for an impossible thing, a crypto system that exactly one third party can intercept. If it's based on a key and the key leaks, it would destroy the modern economy. If it's based on requiring a specific amount of computation, the neighborhood despot buys a billion dollars of computers instead of feeding the people and destroys the modern economy. If more than one government requires such interception capabilities for a single transaction, and the communicating parties involved don't trust all the governments involved, they won't communicate which will destroy the modern economy. If, magically, none of the previous scenarios play out, anybody who wants to communicate securely will have the enormous burden of complying with the regulations of all of the involved governments, slowing down commerce and innovation, and potentially destroying the modern economy. If there's a government key server that dispenses a public key for government snooping and it goes down/a competing government redirects to its own key/DNS or BGP is poisoned/etc. then someone else gets all the traffic and destroys the modern economy. Beyond the economy it's a matter of trust. For the relatively small benefit of a very slight (or even zero) reduction in terrorist incidents, there's simply nobody who can be trusted with the power to snoop on everything.
- mc32 11y agoSo, yes, one of the above. Depends on how countries might negotiate and they can have rules and penalties for rule breaking, just like they do for most other things. What I don't get is one the one hand it's too expensive for governments to do effective snooping (too much data to sift) but on the other hand trust would be broken because everyone could find anything... but governments would be incapable of finding information that same trust breaking information. 1. despots already leave their populations unfed, the world keeps on going. 2. commerce happened before encryption. There hasn't been good reliable and easy to use encryption till the last couple of years. it's not as if the world hadn't globalized despite that. 3. There are already a lot of rules which apply to international commerce, this add very little in comparison. 4. Govt's who want to share in this scheme agree to rules and penalties for breaking them.
- nitrogen 11y ago