4 ms·
Large enough growth markets can tell the Apples etc. that they can either allow interception for surveillance or abandon their market [not too dissimilarly from
by mc32 11y ago
Large enough growth markets can tell the Apples etc. that they can either allow interception for surveillance or abandon their market [not too dissimilarly from what Saudi Arabia did with BB] see [1]. I don't think Apple and Google would simply give up on the biggest two markets to take a stand and allow local counterparts eager to comply to take their growth markets away. It's possible of course they take a stand, but I don't think they would. If not the local operators, then BlackBerry would comply.
[1]http://www.brighthand.com/news/rim-vs-india-and-saudi-arabia-lets-make-a-deal-on-encrypted-data/ http://www.brighthand.com/news/rim-vs-india-and-saudi-arabia...
- aianus 11y agoThat's an argument against centralized encryption with corporate sponsors. Says nothing about government ability to control distributed applications of open-source crypto.
- mc32 11y agoBut now you are asking terrorists to be good at encryption meanwhile even encryption vendors/developers get sloppy and wrong. It's one thing to ask a cell member, hey, here's a phone, it only has this app on it. Don't mod it, don't do anything but use this app. Versus, hey, please implement a secure encryption protocol and make sure there are no exploitable bugs. Also, if the government controls the carriers, they ultimately control what can run on the handset [if they choose to be draconian]. Also, for a big enough growth market, I think they'd be willing to centralize encryption. They'll outwardly say, no impossible, can't be done. Host country will say, sorry, you can't sell here, can't be done. Secret high-level talks happen and mysteriously the handsets are available again.
- sarciszewski 11y ago> meanwhile even encryption vendors get sloppy and wrong. What is an encryption vendor, exactly? Is Open Whisper Systems an encryption vendor? They're pioneers in secure messaging, and they give it away for free. https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/signal-private-messenger/id874139669?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/signal-private-messenger/id8... Is Paragon Initiative Enterprises an encryption vendor? We published Halite, a PHP library to wrap libsodium and make it even harder to use incorrectly. (Users don't even have to know what a nonce is.) https://paragonie.com/project/halite https://paragonie.com/project/halite Or are you speaking about software vendors that erroneously implement their own cryptography features? If so, I totally agree. They do sloopy work.
- nitrogen 11y agoCryptography exists independently from any corporation that may or may not use it in a messaging system.
- mc32 11y agoUnless ISIS, etc. have better crypto minds than the likes of firms who spend billions in that domain (and still make mistakes), you're asking a lot from foot soldier terrorists by asking them to produce, to borrow from oracle, "unbreakable" bug free comms platform.
- nitrogen 11y agoBut it already exists. PGP and couriers. Taking encryption away from the innocent doesn't change that.
- mc32 11y agoThat slows down things. It also allows currier interception. If it's so easy, then, go ahead, replace all your daily encryption with gpg and couriers, see how effective you become.
- nitrogen 11y agoIt would also kill our modern economy. But it wouldn't prevent terrorism.
- mc32 11y agoHow would a hypothetical governments requiring mitm interception capability "kill the modern economy"? If China, The EU etc required it, others would follow... Ordinary people would keep on using gov't mandated mitm encrypted comms and apps. So long as there was protection from your neighbor snooping on you, and the gov't guarantees [whatever that means] it won't use it against you except in "combating terror" most people would go along with it. Just as with disease, you're not looking to eliminate it, you're looking to minimize it.