3 ms·
I'm not sure "commercial" is quite fair, since all the money goes to a charitable foundation. This is still clearly a misuse of copyright, but their intentions
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
I'm not sure "commercial" is quite fair, since all the money goes to a charitable foundation. This is still clearly a misuse of copyright, but their intentions may actually be noble.
Edit: I haven't said anything that wasn't strictly factual. Please don't downvote me because you mistakenly think I was defending copyright abuse.
- jacquesm 11y agoThey are about to lose their jobs and/or relevance. What happens to the money is less important than that her book is free to read for everybody, it's a very important historical document, especially given the rise of the new right wing element in Europe. This is not the first time there is financial controversy around the diary, the last time a lot of money changed hands to be able to show an additional 5 pages. Note that the people in charge of the foundation never said that this was to make sure the foundation would still receive funds, they claimed the opposite, this was not about the money, this was about 'protecting Anne Frank'. I fear that she's very much beyond needing any such protection. Citation from the article: "“When she died, she was a young girl who was not even 16. We are protecting her. That is our task.”"
- cwyers 11y agoEvery institution, over time, seems to morph so that the perpetuation of that institution becomes its top priority, even at the expense of the mission it was founded to serve.
- duaneb 11y agoWhat could be a better charity than putting the work in the public domain?
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoLife-saving food and medical supplies? I mean, I'm not saying that putting the book in the public domain will cut off major charitable funding, but you needn't be quite so flip.
- jacquesm 11y agoBy that reasoning we should rescind the public domain and re-assign all copyright to charitable foundations.
- duaneb 11y agoSure, but I sincerely hope our life-saving food and medical supply is not utterly dependent on people putting money into cultural touchstones. Seems like combining two radically different things.
- tobltobs 11y agoWould be interesting to know how much money is left for charities after paying the swiss based infrastructure. There FAQ sounds more like Disney then Anne Frank.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe Dutch Anne Frank Stichting has a public page on where their money goes and annual reports but the Swiss foundation does not (I searched their website and could not locate anything resembling financial statements for the past years, but I may have missed them).